Caterina Fugazzola, "Words Like Water: Queer Mobilization and Social Change in China" (Temple UP, 2023)
Sep 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Caterina Fugazzola, an expert on queer mobilization in China, discusses the resilience of the tongzhi movement amidst strict political conditions. She examines how activists use community narratives to foster acceptance without confrontation. From her own academic journey into LGBT issues to the significance of her book's title, 'Words Like Water,' Fugazzola highlights the adaptability and flexibility in activism. Personal stories of acceptance, especially among families, illustrate the nuanced challenges and triumphs faced by queer individuals in China.
Chinese queer activism focuses on non-confrontational, family-oriented narratives to navigate authoritarian challenges and minimize backlash.
The rise of LGBT organizations in China post-decriminalization highlights adaptive strategies in response to political repression and cultural conservatism.
Deep dives
Non-Confrontational Strategies of Queer Activism in China
Queer activism in contemporary China operates through non-confrontational strategies that differ significantly from Western approaches. Rather than employing protests or direct political engagement, Chinese queer organizations often focus on narratives emphasizing community and family values. This approach minimizes the risk of backlash and fosters environments where discussions around sexual identity can occur without overt confrontation. For example, groups prefer family-oriented messaging that resonates well within the culturally conservative context of China, making their activism more effective while avoiding government scrutiny.
The Evolution of LGBT NGOs in China
The landscape of LGBT NGOs in China has transformed notably since the late 1990s, especially after key milestones like the decriminalization of same-sex behavior in 1997 and the removal of homosexuality from the list of mental disorders in 2001. These events coincided with an upsurge in internet access, allowing for the proliferation of LGBT organizations, which transitioned from a few to hundreds within a decade. Researchers observing this period note a rising visibility and the establishment of physical spaces for community engagement, which provided much-needed support networks. However, despite this growth, recent political shifts have posed new challenges, including increased surveillance and repression of queer identities, leading some organizations to adopt more cautious strategies.
PFLAG China's Family-Centric Approach
PFLAG China exemplifies a family-focused model of advocacy, emphasizing parental support while navigating the complexities of sexual identity within a familial context. By shifting the terminology from emphasizing homosexuality to highlighting parental relationships, the organization seeks to create a safer environment for dialogue while minimizing political risks. Their initiatives include sharing sessions where parents recount their children's coming out experiences, fostering a sense of community and understanding among family members. However, this traditional framing risks aligning with homonormative values, potentially excluding diverse queer identities that do not conform to the conventional narrative of familial acceptance.
The Importance of Language in Activism
Language plays a critical role in the strategies adopted by LGBT activists in China, especially concerning the distinction between 'human rights' and 'lawful rights.' Activists strategically reframe their agendas to avoid direct confrontation with the government by focusing on legal violations rather than universal human rights, which can evoke government suppression. For instance, organizations work on lawsuits that clarify issues of false advertising related to conversion therapies rather than claiming broader rights for homosexuals. This nuanced use of language helps to navigate China's complex political landscape, allowing some organizations to maintain their operations despite increasing repression, but also signifies the precarious nature of activism in the current environment.
After China officially “decriminalized” same-sex behavior in 1997, both the visibility and public acceptance of tongzhi, an inclusive identity term that refers to nonheterosexual and gender nonconforming identities in the People’s Republic of China, has improved. However, for all the positive change, there are few opportunities for political and civil rights advocacy under Xi Jinping’s authoritarian rule.
Words Like Water: Queer Mobilization and Social Change in China(Temple UP, 2023) explores the nonconfrontational strategies the tongzhi movement uses in contemporary China. Caterina Fugazzola analyzes tongzhi organizers’ conceptualizations of, and approaches to, social change, explaining how they avoid the backlash that meets Western tactics, such as protests, confrontation, and language about individual freedoms. In contrast, the groups’ intentional use of community and family-oriented narratives, discourses, and understandings of sexual identity are more effective, especially in situations where direct political engagement is not possible.
Providing on-the-ground stories that examine the social, cultural, and political constraints and opportunities, Words like Water emphasizes the value of discursive flexibility that allows activists to adapt to changing social and political conditions.
Caterina Fugazzola is Assistant Senior Instructional Professor of Global Studies at the University of Chicago.
Qing Shen is a PhD candidate in anthropology at Uppsala University, Sweden.