Brandon Showalter, a journalist from the Christian Post and an orthodox Christian, dives into the intricate relationship between gender ideology and the church. He sheds light on how these ideologies are impacting Christian beliefs and traditions. The discussion includes the importance of the Nicene Creed, contrasting views on gender identity within various denominations, and the significance of human rights in a faith context. Brandon also critiques modern gender-affirming practices while emphasizing compassion and the dignity of life amid changing societal norms.
Brandon Showalter highlights the alarming trend of mainstream churches adapting to gender ideology, impacting traditional rituals and practices.
The podcast explores the connection between historical Gnosticism and modern gender identity ideologies, emphasizing a dualistic separation of body and mind.
Showalter emphasizes the necessity for churches to maintain foundational Christian values amid declining attendance and societal pressures toward inclusivity.
Deep dives
Brandon Showalter's Journalism Background
Brandon Showalter is a journalist with the Christian Post, focusing primarily on issues related to gender ideology and its impacts. His career began shortly after the tragic Pulse nightclub shooting, which exposed him to covering controversial topics. Over the years, he has noted alarming trends in how language surrounding gender is being manipulated, as well as the medicalization of gender identity, which he sees as a significant concern. Showalter argues that mainstream media has historically overlooked this pressing issue, but he is starting to witness a shift towards greater scrutiny.
The Intersection of Faith and Gender Ideology
The podcast discusses the complex relationship between various Christian denominations and the acceptance of gender ideology. Showalter points out that many mainline churches, particularly the Episcopal Church and some liberal Lutherans, are adapting their practices to align with trans ideology, changing traditional elements like liturgy and church rituals. He expresses concern over this trend, suggesting that a prophetic voice is crucial for safeguarding women’s rights and protecting children from irreversible medical interventions. This shift in church practice, he argues, reflects broader societal fears that prevent a clear confrontation with the emerging ideologies.
The Role of Gnosticism in Modern Beliefs
Showalter draws parallels between historical Gnosticism and contemporary gender identity ideologies, suggesting that both exhibit a dualistic view separating body and mind. He describes modern gender ideology as a form of 'Neo-Gnosticism' that undermines traditional Christian beliefs regarding the unity of body and spirit. The discussion highlights how Gnostic thought has infiltrated certain denominations, causing confusion about the inherent dignity of the human body. By denying the significance of physical existence, Gnosticism stands in stark contrast to the Christian understanding of redemption and the sanctity of the body.
The Crisis of Mainstream Religious Beliefs
The podcast addresses the alarming decline in church attendance and the challenges faced by various denominations in maintaining relevance. As congregations grapple with issues of inclusivity and compassion towards marginalized groups, those attempting to uphold traditional beliefs often feel pressured to conform. The conversation emphasizes the need for churches to stand firm against ideologies that could potentially erode foundational Christian values, even as attendance dwindles. This crisis has led to some denominations merging or closing, raising questions about the future of organized religion.
Compassion and Consequence in Gender Discussions
There is a critical examination of how compassion and good intentions can be manipulated in discussions surrounding gender identity. The speakers highlight the dangers of well-meaning individuals inadvertently supporting harmful ideologies due to a lack of awareness and understanding. They argue that genuine compassion should not equate to uncritical acceptance of radical changes to one’s body or identity. Instead, they advocate for a deeper understanding of the psychological struggles faced by those questioning their gender while ensuring that such compassion does not compromise the integrity and safety of vulnerable individuals.
Journalist, denominational mutt, and little-o orthodox Christian Brandon Showalter covers the “gender beat” at the Christian Post. He fills us in on how gender ideology is infiltrating churches, and answers: What is a Christian? What is gnosticism? How do denominations differ? What are human rights? What state has the worst drivers? (Maryland.) We also discuss the Nicene Creed, Reality’s Last Stand, heresy, redemption, the flesh, self-idolatry, bioethics, the rise of the “nones”, evangelism, zealotry, sex scandals, martyrdom, persecution complexes, and how resistance to gender ideology is overcoming political divides. In the words of the world’s most beloved un-killable zombie, you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free (John 8:31).
