The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture WOF 512: The Development of Christian Doctrine (4 of 12)
13 snips
Oct 20, 2025 The discussion dives into Newman's influential thoughts on the evolution of Christian doctrine. It highlights his careful navigation of the debates around papal authority and infallibility. Newman's work stands as a response to historical consciousness, arguing that doctrine develops authentically over time. Listeners learn about the rich interplay between faith and reason and how ideas naturally progress, illustrated through the Willis Tower analogy. The podcast captures the ongoing dialogue about the Church's teachings and the layers of meaning that unfold through history.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Doctrine As Living History
- Newman argues doctrine should be seen historically as alive and evolving rather than fixed and timeless.
- He frames development as the doctrine becoming more fully itself through unfolding over time.
Limits Of Back-to-Source Approaches
- Newman rejects both Protestant sola-scriptura and Vincent's 'always, everywhere, by all' as adequate methods.
- He proposes development as the better account of how authentic doctrine emerges amid change.
Ideas Grow Through Active Minds
- Newman shows that ideas never sit passively in minds but are compared, abstracted, and reworked through discourse.
- This restless mental play produces new aspects and deepens objectivity of an idea over time.
