
The Nietzsche Podcast 123: Rust Cohle & The Flat Circle - Philosophy of True Detective
Oct 28, 2025
Explore the philosophical depths of True Detective, where time is a flat circle reminiscent of Nietzsche's Eternal Return. Delve into the contrast between Rust Cohle's bleak view of existence and Martin Hart's traditional beliefs. Uncover the show's cosmic horror, focusing on human cruelty rather than supernatural threats. Analyze the cult's Gnostic-like ideologies and their nihilistic rituals. Finally, consider Rust's journey from pessimism to a mystical revelation, questioning whether he embodies Nietzschean ideals or simply seeks truth amidst chaos.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Horror Is Cosmic Indifference
- True Detective frames horror as cosmic indifference rather than supernatural Satanism.
- The show evokes Lovecraftian dread by exposing a cold universe that treats humans like insects.
Consciousness As A Tragic Misstep
- Rust Cohle presents a Schopenhauerian pessimism: consciousness is a tragic evolutionary mistake.
- He argues antinatalism and denial of reproduction as an honorable escape from suffering.
Flat Circle Meets Gnostic Trap
- The cult's 'time is a flat circle' mixes Nietzsche's eternal return with Gnostic ideas of a trapped, evil world.
- Members see cyclical existence as a prison they either despair over or seek to transcend through transgression.






