The Atheist Experience 27.49 12-10-2023 with Johnny P Angel and Forrest Valkai
Dec 11, 2023
auto_awesome
Atheist guests Johnny P Angel and Forrest Valkai discuss issues of Genesis, Unicorns, suffering, reproduction, and babies hating god. They explore the misconception of hating God when not believing in its existence. The hosts engage in a lighthearted conversation about discussing fictional characters. They also touch on topics like evolution and reproduction, the concept of suffering in an atheist worldview, and life without belief in God or an afterlife. They address the conflict between Genesis and the theory of evolution and explore the differences between Judaism and Christianity.
Evolution is the logical outcome of reproduction and the natural process of life adapting to different environments.
The existence of life on Earth does not require a supernatural cause or purpose.
Humanism seeks to eliminate needless suffering and improve society.
The biblical account of creation does not align with scientific understanding of evolution.
Sin encompasses actions leading to various forms of death and may not be universally shared.
Deep study and understanding of the Bible in its original context is necessary for a deeper understanding of God's message.
Deep dives
Evolution and Purpose
The listener explores the connection between evolution and the biblical idea of purpose in life. They wonder if the innate urge to reproduce complements the viewpoint in the Bible.
The Logical Outcome of Reproduction
The AI assistant explains that evolution is the logical outcome of reproduction and the natural process of life adapting to different environments. It points out that the diversity and complexity of life today is the result of billions of years of evolution.
Life and the Universe
The AI assistant emphasizes that the existence of life on Earth does not require a supernatural cause or purpose. It cites scientific evidence of the origins of life and the natural processes that led to the development of complex organisms.
The Scale of the Universe
The AI assistant discusses the vastness of the universe and the perception of human insignificance in the face of its immense size. It highlights the concept that life exists due to the probability of certain events occurring given the vastness of time and space.
The Meaning of Suffering
In this podcast episode, the discussion centers around the meaning of suffering. The speaker emphasizes that religion often provides a narrative framework for understanding and enduring suffering. However, the podcast hosts argue that humanism seeks to eliminate needless suffering and improve society. The conversation emphasizes the importance of finding personal fulfillment and addressing societal issues to reduce suffering.
Interpreting the Bible
The discussion touches on the interpretation of biblical texts, specifically the account of creation and the role of water. The hosts point out that the chronological order and origins described in the Bible do not align with scientific understanding of evolution. They also address the role of water in biblical narratives, highlighting that interpretations can differ and that later writings may build upon earlier ones in an attempt to continue the overarching theme.
Beliefs about Sin and Morality
The conversation delves into the concept of sin and its relationship to morality. The speaker argues that sin encompasses actions leading to various forms of death, whether physical, mental, emotional, or societal. While acknowledging that different Christians may have differing views, the speaker believes that sin can be seen in any action leading to death. However, they also acknowledge that these beliefs may not be universally shared.
Exploring Evidence for Evolution
The speakers discuss the evidence for evolution mentioned in a previous conversation. They explore the idea of sin as actions leading to death and how it relates to biological health issues like cancer. The hosts pose questions about the limits and scope of sin in various situations, such as alcohol consumption and exposure to carcinogens. The conversation revolves around the speakers' religious beliefs and their interpretations of sin and its manifestations.
The limitations of human understanding and the importance of faith in God
In this podcast episode, the speaker discusses the limitations of human understanding and the importance of having faith in God. The speaker argues that humans cannot fully comprehend the complexities of creation and that our knowledge is limited compared to God's infinite wisdom. Therefore, it is necessary to have faith and trust in God's plan, even if it may seem confusing or contradictory to our limited understanding.
The problem of evil and the concept of free will
Another key point discussed in the podcast is the problem of evil and the existence of suffering in the world. The speaker acknowledges the existence of pain, disease, and other forms of suffering, especially in the context of pediatric diseases and birth defects. The speaker attributes these hardships to the fallen state of the world caused by human sin and emphasizes that sin is not directly connected to the suffering of innocent individuals. The concept of free will is also brought up, suggesting that God created humans with the ability to choose between right and wrong, even though this can lead to the potential for sin and suffering.
Interpreting the Bible and the importance of deep study
The podcast episode delves into the interpretation of the Bible and the necessity of deep study to understand its teachings. The speaker argues that there are often misunderstandings and misconceptions about the nature of God and the Bible due to cultural influences and individual interpretations. The speaker emphasizes the significance of studying the biblical text in its original context, taking into account language changes and the evolution of human knowledge. It is suggested that through thorough study and a humble search for truth, one can find a deeper understanding of God's message.
In today’s episode of the Atheist Experience, Forest Valkai and Johnny P. Angel works through issues of Genesis, Unicorns, suffering, reproduction and babies hating god.
Ray in WV says that asks if the hosts believe we evolved from higher apes He then states that god is sovereign and every human hates god when they are born. The scientific argument is not if evolution happened, but how and why. Why do you think there is a god? How does a baby know there is a god to hate? How can one hate something when they don’t believe it exists? How do you know that god exists? We feel the same way about Yahweh as we do other mythological villains and fictional antagonists. Our explanations for how the universe came about are based on evidence. How much time have you spent talking with people who don’t already agree with what you think? Being a Christian does not give you the ability to have a monopoly on goodness.
Camden in NC asks if the innate response of evolutionary reproduction compliments what god says in the bible. Reproduction is one way that we classify what is and is not alive. If something did not reproduce, we would not know about it and evolution is the logical outcome of reproduction. We did not suddenly jump from a worm with no eyes to a human with eyes. Once the earth cooled from this fiery hello, life appeared relatively quick, and this can show that it is possible for life to arise without needing a cause. There are certain biological constants throughout history that have been developed through evolution and can be seen in many cultures.
Andrew in FL says religion gives meaning to suffering and that atheism makes suffering meaningless. Atheism does not have the narrative that religion does, however humanism helps reduce unnecessary suffering. What is the issue with not seeing the meaning to human suffering or existence? Religion has been used by powerful groups to convince us that we should just accept that suffering has a greater purpose. What do you think about rooting out the causes of suffering and fixing it? The current work structure is not a call from god, it is a call from capitalism. If you did not believe in a god, and you believed this is the only life you have, what would you do for your life, family, and career?
CJ in KS references a previous call where he had evidence for Eve's creation from Adam’s rib and is calling to develop the conversation. He explains that the water mentioned in Genesis is a manifestation of Jesus. The writers of Genesis did not know there would be writers of John. The people who wrote the Bible had access to earlier writings, not the other way around. The later writing does not prove the book is true, but rather develops the theme. Why do you believe the Bible is not just a literary book? How is sin anything that causes death? What about children who die from SIDS? Do you believe in a literal hell?
Thank you for tuning in! Question of the week: What is an inappropriate thing to say or do at a holiday party?
