Lacan, Genre, and the Enjoyment of Music with David Burke and Acid Horizon
Mar 11, 2024
auto_awesome
Exploring the relationship between heavy metal culture and psychoanalytic concepts, political engagement in metal music, and the transformative power of music events. Discussing Lacanian theories on pleasure and enjoyment, genre boundaries in music evolution, and the unique experience of metal and dance music genres.
Different music genres evoke varying forms of enjoyment, from phallic elements in death metal to metaphorical enjoyment in dance music.
Technological advancements have led to a homogenization of music genres, altering the discovery-driven consumption experience.
Live music offers a more intense and immersive enjoyment compared to recorded playback, highlighting the transformative impact of technological changes.
Deep dives
Exploring Enjoyment in Music and Psychoanalysis
The discussion delves into the concept of enjoyment in music through the lens of psychoanalysis, particularly focusing on how different genres of music evoke varied forms of enjoyment. The analysis includes exploring the idea of phallic enjoyment in death metal, feelings of embodiment in dance music, and how R&B is filtered through the social field. The conversation goes deeper into how psychoanalytic concepts, especially the death drive, play a role in producing enjoyment in music.
Distinguishing Phallic and Other's Enjoyment in Music Genres
The podcast examines the distinction between phallic enjoyment and the other's enjoyment in music genres. It highlights how masculinity is associated with phallic enjoyment, characterized by direct stimulation such as in death metal lyrics, while femininity leans towards the other's enjoyment that passes through the social field and is more metaphorical. The discussion explores how genres like dance music embody phallic elements and genres like indie rock and R&B align more with the other's enjoyment.
Implications of Genre Evolution and Music Consumption
The conversation extends to the evolution of genres and the impact of technological advancements on music consumption. It discusses how the mass homogenization of music genres in the digital age affects the experience of enjoyment, leading to a shift from a quest for discovery to a continuous yet possibly less vibrant engagement with music. The dialogue touches on the significance of live music experiences in the context of prevalent recorded playback entertainment.
Conclusion: Live Music and Adventurous Engagement
In conclusion, the discussion underlines the significance of live music experiences in offering a heightened level of enjoyment compared to recorded music consumption. It emphasizes the adventurous and immersive nature of attending live gigs as a form of pure enjoyment, contrasting with the more passive pleasure derived from pre-recorded music. The dialogue reflects on the transformative impact of technological changes on music engagement and the ways in which live music retains its intensity in an era of digital abundance.
Exploring the Neurological Structure of Enjoyment in Relation to Metal Fandom
The podcast delves into the intriguing connection between neurological structure, enjoyment, and metal fandom. It suggests that metal's appeal to individuals with autism spectrum and ADHD behaviors may stem from how its phallic enjoyment aligns with their thinking patterns. The discussion extends to considering musical genres as reflective of diverse neurological structures, hinting at how listeners' enjoyment may be linked to their neurological makeup.
Challenges in Genre Differentiation and the Evolution of Musical Experimentation
The episode navigates the complexities of genre differentiation and musical experimentation within metal and beyond. It raises questions about how subgenres and musical experiments impact the traditional orthodoxy of genres like metal. The conversation explores the balance between mainstream success and experimental integrity, emphasizing the evolving nature of musical genres and the ethical considerations tied to genre evolution and experimentation.
Absent Signifier (David's free metal band): https://www.instagram.com/absentsignifierband?igsh=ZzhvbWpvczg5aWkw
Can Lacanian theory explain our enjoyment of musical genres? Adam and Craig of Acid Horizon sit down with musicologist David Burke to discuss what makes metal phallic, why dance music is akin to the Other's jouissance, and more.
