Sam Roggeveen, the Director of the Lowy Institute's International Security Program, discusses the recent maneuvers of Chinese military ships near Australia. He analyzes whether these actions indicate aggression or a defensive posture and the implications for Australia's security. Roggeveen proposes an 'echidna strategy,' emphasizing the need for Australia to enhance its own defense capabilities amid shifting U.S. commitments. He also critiques the current defense focus, highlighting the importance of advanced missile systems and base protection.
The recent presence of Chinese military ships near Australia has provoked concerns about regional security and reliance on U.S. defense support.
Australia's defense strategy is shifting toward independent capabilities, emphasizing anti-ship and air defenses to deter potential threats from China.
Deep dives
Chinese Naval Activities Near Australia
The presence of a Chinese naval flotilla off the coast of Australia has raised concerns regarding regional security. This flotilla consisted of a large destroyer, a frigate, and a supply ship, demonstrating China’s naval capabilities. Although these activities were conducted in international waters and were not illegal, they were perceived as provocative, particularly when live fire drills disrupted flights in Sydney. Observers note that while such naval maneuvers are routine in other regions like Taiwan or Japan, this is novel for Australia, prompting extensive media coverage and public concern.
Implications for Australian Defense Policy
The actions of the Chinese Navy signal a shift in regional power dynamics and challenge Australia's reliance on the United States for security. Analysts argue that the longstanding commitment of the U.S. to its allies in Asia has wavered over the past few decades, raising questions about Australia’s ability to defend itself independently. There is a growing consensus that Australia must enhance its own defense capabilities, focusing on anti-ship and air defenses to counter any potential threats from the Chinese military. This call for independent action is highlighted as a critical shift in Australian defense strategy, especially in the wake of fluctuating U.S. military presence in the region.
Adopting a New Defense Strategy
Proposals for an 'echidna strategy' aim to revert to a defense doctrine that prioritizes protecting Australia’s maritime and air approaches. This includes investments in advanced missile technology and stronger anti-aircraft systems to better deter foreign naval forces. Instead of expensive submarines that may provoke conflict, this strategy seeks to maintain a lower profile while ensuring robust self-defense capabilities. By emphasizing resilience through independent defense measures, Australia could increase its security without escalating tensions with major powers like China.
Over the past month, a flotilla of Chinese military ships came close to Australian shores unannounced.
They conducted live-fire drills off the coast of Eden, New South Wales – disrupting dozens of flights out of Sydney airport.
The Chinese ships have arrived at a time when Australia’s ability to rely on the United States for defence is questionable, and their presence has sparked concerns that we’re unable to handle our own security in the event of an attack.
Today, Director of the Lowy Institute’s International Security Program, Sam Roggeveen, on why the Chinese military circled Australia – and what we should do about it.
If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support.