Mary Midgley, an influential philosopher known for her work on metaphilosophy and morality, takes center stage. She passionately critiques reductionism and scientism, advocating for a holistic understanding of human experience. The conversation dives into her renowned writings and rich philosophical insights, emphasizing the importance of context in moral choices. Midgley's engaging style and unique life journey shine through, alongside light-hearted anecdotes about her signature hats. The episode also touches on the philosophical contributions of women in the 20th century.
Mary Midgley emphasizes philosophy as a vital background activity that informs our daily decisions and understanding of life.
She critiques reductionism and scientism, advocating for a more integrated approach to understanding human behavior and ethical dilemmas.
Midgley promotes a pluralistic view of morality, likening it to a forest with diverse trees that reflects contextual ethical reasoning.
Deep dives
Introduction to Mary Midgley
Mary Midgley, a notable philosopher of the late 20th and early 21st centuries, made significant contributions to discussions on human nature and ethics. Known affectionately as the 'hat lady' for her distinctive style, Midgley published her first book, 'Beast and Man: The Roots of Human Nature', at the age of 50. This work laid the foundation for her career, leading to further exploration of themes such as morality, reductionism, and societal interconnectedness. Her last book, 'What is Philosophy For?', released shortly before her passing at 99, encapsulates her philosophical journey and ongoing relevance in contemporary thought.
Midgley's Perspective on Philosophy
Midgley views philosophy as a continuous and essential background activity that shapes our understanding of life. She argues that philosophy is not a mere academic endeavor, but rather a fundamental part of our daily decision-making processes, akin to driving a car. Through her works, she emphasizes the importance of plumbing the depths of human experience, suggesting that philosophical inquiry aids in uncovering profound insights often hidden beneath the surface. This metaphor of plumbing connects to her belief in philosophy's vital role in addressing the complexities of existence.
Critique of Reductionism and Scientism
Midgley critiques reductionism, the tendency to oversimplify complex phenomena into their simplest components, leading to an incomplete understanding of human behavior. She argues that focusing solely on biological or genetic factors ignores crucial social, cultural, and psychological dimensions of humanity. Furthermore, she challenges scientism, the belief that science can provide answers to all questions, including moral and existential ones, asserting that such an approach fails to capture the depth of human experience. Midgley's work calls for a more integrative understanding of human nature that recognizes the interplay between various factors influencing behavior.
Ethics and Moral Philosophy
In her ethical philosophy, Midgley promotes a pluralistic approach, arguing that no single moral framework can adequately address the complexity of moral issues. She likens morality to a forest with many trees, emphasizing the need to appreciate the diversity of moral perspectives. This viewpoint aligns with her belief that ethical decisions must consider the context of individual circumstances and societal influences, rather than relying solely on empirical data. Midgley pushes back against utilitarianism, advocating for a deeper understanding of altruism and cooperation in ethical reasoning.
The Interconnectedness of Human Relationships
Midgley emphasizes the interconnectedness of human relationships, asserting that individual actions cannot be understood in isolation. She critiques the idea of the autonomous individual, arguing instead that our values and moral beliefs are shaped by cultural heritage and communal life. This holistic perspective suggests that understanding human nature and ethics requires examining the broader context of societal relationships. Midgley’s approach highlights the importance of empathy and the shared human experience in navigating moral dilemmas, reaffirming her belief in the necessity of a comprehensive understanding of humanity.
We finish our overview of The Oxford Four with Mr. Parsons' favorite, Mary Midgley. She wrote on the topic of metaphilosophy, championed a pluralistic view of morality, and raged against scientism and reductionism. AND she had swaggy hats!
Contact us via email at contact@opendoorphilosophy.com Open Door Philosophy on Instagram @opendoorphilosophy Open Door Philosophy website at opendoorphilosophy.com
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode