Tangle As states adopt phone bans, a debate emerges on what to do next.
15 snips
Sep 17, 2025 As schools grapple with cell phone use, 17 states have implemented new restrictions. Supporters argue these laws enhance focus and reduce cyberbullying, while opponents raise concerns about equity and enforcement. The discussion also highlights the need for local, student-inclusive solutions rather than outright bans. Additionally, a listener question explores the implications of a recent International Court of Justice advisory on climate change. Join the exploration of technology's role in education and its broader societal impact.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Patchwork Of Phone Policies
- States and districts vary widely in phone rules, from incentives to full-day bans for different ages.
- Research links phones to lower achievement and wellbeing, but findings are mixed across studies and countries.
Secondhand Phone Distraction
- Phones create a "secondhand smoke" distraction where many students are distracted by others' devices.
- Proponents argue bans restore social interaction and allow students to develop social skills during school time.
Real-World Phone Ban Success Story
- Gilbert Skirch described a school-year phone ban where students handed phones at entry and consequences were strict.
- He reported more conversation, faster teaching, less cyberbullying, and fewer classroom distractions.
