Rebecca Traister, author of All the Single Ladies: Unmarried Women and the Rise of an Independent Nation and writer, discusses the renewed interest in marriage as a means to address American poverty. They delve into the societal perception of marriage, the historical context of marriage panics, the link between marriage panics and race, and the problematic notion of marriage as an easy fix for societal inequities.
The historical context of marriage discourses reveals their racial biases and failure to account for systemic racism.
Promoting marriage as a solution overlooks the complexities of relationships and fails to address underlying economic and social inequities.
Deep dives
Marriage Panic and the Link to Race
Marriage panics about singlehood and marriage have arisen throughout history, often linked to race and failing to account for racism. In the 1960s, the Moynihan Report identified single black mothers as a cause of poverty, ignoring the government interventions that undermined black families, while privileging white families with policy support. This historical context sheds light on the current marriage discourse that emphasizes the benefits of marriage, overlooking the complexities and individual experiences of relationships.
The Two Parent Privilege
The publication of the book 'The Two Parent Privilege' has reignited discussions about the advantages of two-parent households. The book argues that marriage is a solution to a range of problems, particularly related to children, suggesting that it should be treated as a serious policy issue. However, the author overlooks the complexities of relationships, including the possibility of unstable or abusive marriages. Furthermore, promoting marriage as a solution fails to address the underlying economic and social inequities that prevent many individuals from forming stable relationships.
Addressing Inequities
Instead of focusing on promoting marriage as a policy goal, there are more impactful measures that can foster healthy families and support children. Policies such as providing economic resources, affordable housing, and accessible healthcare can directly improve the well-being of families and children. Emphasizing marriage as the primary solution ignores the potential for government interventions to address the root causes of inequities and assist all types of families in thriving.
Why is everyone—on the left and the right—suddenly touting the benefits of a married two-parent family? And what is it about this institution that appeals to a certain class of politicians and pundits as means to address American poverty, even as it loses popularity?
We consider the public meltdown over lower marriage rates and the renewed interest in ending no-fault divorce.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Madeline Ducharme, Anna Phillips, Paige Osburn, and Rob Gunther.