What is alienation? The development and legacy of Marx’s early theory
Jan 13, 2022
auto_awesome
This podcast explores Marx's theory of alienation and its impact on practical organizing. It discusses conflicting interpretations, the development of Marx's thought from his early manuscripts to his later work, and the concept of alienation in relation to human nature and capitalism. It also explores the importance of historically determined structures and the interconnectedness of things in Marx's theory.
Marx's theory of alienation explores the impact of capitalism on workers in terms of their estrangement from the product of their labor, their own activity, and their species being.
Marx's theory highlights the need to move beyond preconceived notions of human nature and focus on the historical, economic, and social structures that shape humanity.
Deep dives
Marx's Theory of Alienation
Marx's theory of alienation explores the impact of capitalism on workers in terms of their estrangement from the product of their labor, their own activity, and their species being. He argues that in a capitalist society, workers are alienated from the fruits of their labor, as the results of production belong to the capitalist or landlord. Furthermore, workers are estranged from their own relationship to their work, making their labor an alien activity. This estrangement extends to the human essence, as individuals become separated from their life activity and their species being, thus leading to the estrangement of humans from one another.
Historical Context and Debates
Marx's manuscripts on alienation were not published during his lifetime and only gained wider recognition in the early 20th century. Debates surrounding the manuscripts emerged in the Soviet Union, with some embracing the concept of alienation as a way to challenge the Soviet Union's class orthodoxy. However, critics argued that this interpretation obscured class struggle and reintroduced Hegelian idealism into Marx's theory. Ultimately, Marx's theory highlights the need to move beyond preconceived notions of human nature and focus on the historical, economic, and social structures that shape humanity.
Abstraction in Capitalism
In his work Capital, Marx discusses the concept of abstraction in relation to capitalism. He points out that capital abstracts labor by treating different forms of labor as equivalent, leading to the alienation of labor from workers. The capitalist mode of production itself is an abstraction, guiding societal organization without a physical form. Marx emphasizes that understanding and challenging this abstract system requires a dialectical method linked to the practice of class struggle. Ultimately, Marx's theory advocates for a revolutionary movement that fosters optimism, flexibility, and the unleashing of human potential beyond the confines of capitalist value production.
Editorial Collective Note: This is a new introduction to alienation that replaces our earlier introduction written in 2006. It’s part of our renovation and expansion of our “Fundamentals of Marxism” series and other articles on Marxist theory and the class struggle.
Offering a brief introduction to Marx’s theory of alienation is not a straightforward task. This is due, in part, to conflicting interpretations of key aspects of Marx’s project directly related to alienation, the timing of the publication of Marx’s early manuscripts where the theory is articulated, and the political contexts in which it was taken up. Central to any theory of alienation are questions of the nature of existence, which are often posed this way: Is there a natural or timeless essence from which the human could be alienated? While this question has preoccupied many academics, our most important task is to consider the impact of debates around alienation on our practical, day-to-day organizing.
In this article, we introduce Marx’s writing on alienation as they appear in the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, before discussing the historical context of their publication. We then chart the development of Marx’s thought from the manuscripts to his later work that is grounded in dialectical and historical materialism. Marx’s early works conceive “human nature” as an essential and ahistorical condition from which capital alienates workers, while, as we show, his later work focuses on capital’s process of abstraction and conceives of the human as a process of production, and therefore as dynamic and contingent on the mode of production.
Read the full article:
https://www.liberationschool.org/13-what-is-alienation-html/
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode