Effectively Wild: A FanGraphs Baseball Podcast

Effectively Wild Episode 2383: How to Call a Collapse

9 snips

Oct 4, 2025

In this lively discussion, Michael Baumann, a Fangraphs editor, and Jason Benetti, the Tigers' TV broadcaster, delve into the wild world of baseball. They explore the emotional aftermath of the Guardians' stunning collapse and the Tigers' reprieve from elimination. Jason shares insights on calling the Tigers’ rollercoaster season, while Michael celebrates Cam Schlittler's historic performance. The duo also discusses division series matchups, highlighting must-see series and intriguing players to watch. Expect humor, analysis, and heartfelt baseball talk!

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Reliever Familiarity Reduces Edge

Reliever familiarity from facing the same hitters late in the season can blunt bullpen effectiveness.
Ben and Michael suggested overexposure to opponents likely reduced the Guardians' reliever edge.

INSIGHT

Bullpens Need Leads To Matter

A dominant bullpen only helps if your team can take a lead to protect.
Ben and Michael note the Padres' elite pen failed to matter because their offense couldn't produce timely leads.

INSIGHT

Bad Calls Feel Worse Today

Modern strike-zone consistency makes egregious calls stand out and cause outsized outrage.
Ben and Michael argued the Bogarts low strike in the Padres-Cubs game felt worse because we're used to more accurate zones.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app