Novara FM: Motherhood In and Against the State w/ Helen Charman
Aug 29, 2024
auto_awesome
Helen Charman, a literary scholar and historian, delves into the political history of motherhood in the UK and Ireland. She examines the historical and modern use of maternal metaphors in politics, discussing how figures like Margaret Thatcher impacted perceptions of motherhood. Charman critiques the austerity measures affecting marginalized families while highlighting the liberatory potential of motherhood. The conversation also touches on activism at Greenham Common, the challenges faced by diverse parenting structures, and reimagining maternal roles within feminist movements.
Helen Charman's book illustrates how the politicization of motherhood can symbolize both oppression and liberation within state power dynamics.
The podcast critiques the paternalistic framing of fiscal policies, drawing parallels between household budgeting and government spending as misleading narratives.
Motherhood's role in activism highlights the necessity for a communal approach to parenting, promoting collective responsibility for societal change.
Deep dives
Fiscal Management and Political Identity
The episode emphasizes how Rachel Reeves, the soon-to-be Chancellor of the UK, invokes familial budgeting principles to frame her political identity. Reeves draws parallels between managing a household and government fiscal responsibilities, echoing ideologies of former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. This paternalistic view of fiscal management is portrayed as misleading since households do not generate revenue through taxation, a fundamental difference that highlights the complexity of state funding. The episode critiques this narrative as a tool used to validate significant cuts to state spending on public services such as health and transportation.
Motherhood and State Power
Helen Charman’s book, 'Mother State,' explores the nuanced relationship between motherhood and state power, arguing that motherhood can signify both oppression and liberation. The podcast discusses historical contexts where women, often marginalized, have fought against systemic injustices while simultaneously embodying maternal roles. Their activism, including efforts for nuclear disarmament and emergency housing, demonstrates how motherhood transcends mere biological connection to become a catalyst for social change. This duality sheds light on the different ways motherhood can be politicized according to state objectives.
The Legacy of Thatcher and Maternal Imagery
Margaret Thatcher's legacy is explored as both a symbol of maternal authority and a rejection of nurturing roles, complicating the concept of motherhood in political discourse. The episode delves into how Thatcher's policies negatively impacted mothers and children while simultaneously using maternal archetypes to justify stringent austerity measures. By labeling Thatcher as the 'milk snatcher,' it points to her paradoxical embrace of maternal imagery while undermining its associated values of care and protection. This historical analysis serves to caution against contemporary politicians who might similarly exploit maternal narratives for political gain.
Political Implications of Mothering
The discussion emphasizes that motherhood is inherently political and cannot be separated from broader societal structures and governance. This viewpoint challenges the notion that maternal identity exists in a vacuum, detached from systemic issues affecting women and their families. It argues that societal policies, particularly austerity measures, disproportionately impact mothers, reinforcing economic and social inequalities. As such, understanding motherhood's role within political frameworks is essential for advocating for policies that align with women’s actual needs and experiences.
Collective Responsibility and Revolutionary Potential
The episode posits that genuine motherhood transcends individual ownership and fosters a sense of collective responsibility among communities. This idea is illustrated through examples from activist movements where mothers band together to support one another, redefining motherhood as a shared societal responsibility. The narrative advocates for a reimagined societal structure that prioritizes communal care over privatized notions of parenting, suggesting that valuing interconnections can lead to transformative social change. The podcast ultimately encourages listeners to consider a broader familial concept rooted in mutual aid and collective upliftment, facilitating social progress.
Motherhood was once at the centre of the feminist movement’s demands, from campaigns for reproductive rights to the mobilisation of anti-nuclear mums at Greenham Common. But in the 21st century, the politicisation of mothering seems to have shrunk in its ambition. In her new book Mother State: A Political History of Motherhood, literary scholar and […]
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode