In this engaging discussion, technology journalist Paul Thurrott, renowned for his expertise in the Windows ecosystem, shares insights on the memorable year Windows has had and what lies ahead in 2025. They dive into the implications of Windows 10 reaching end-of-support, the significance of security initiatives, and perceptions of Windows as an 'open platform.' Paul also discusses cost-effective solutions from Ignite, and the growing trend of companies shifting back to on-premises solutions, all while mixing in a festive spirit for the holiday season!
The possibility of Windows evolving into a Linux-based distribution presents significant technical challenges and is deemed more fantasy than reality.
Despite Microsoft's advancements in the Windows Resiliency Initiative, concerns persist regarding inadequate responses to critical security vulnerabilities and transparent communication.
Deep dives
The Future of Windows and Linux Integration
There is a discussion regarding the potential future of Windows evolving into a Linux distribution, complete with a Microsoft-specific desktop environment. This idea stems from a listener's comment that envisions Windows using the Linux kernel while retaining compatibility with legacy Windows applications through virtualization. However, the speakers highlight the significant technical challenges involved, as well as the unlikelihood of such a transformation occurring while influential figures within Microsoft remain active. They liken this notion to 'fan fiction', acknowledging the appeal of a Linux-based Windows while asserting that it's more of a dream than a feasible outcome.
Windows as the 'Most Open Operating System'
During a recent session at Ignite, a Windows executive controversially claimed that Windows is the 'most open operating system,' which sparked significant backlash and debate. This statement is viewed with skepticism due to Microsoft's history regarding security vulnerabilities and privacy concerns. Critics pointed out that this assertion seemed disconnected from recent security incidents, particularly after the CrowdStrike breach, where blame was directed at Microsoft by some parties. The response from Microsoft focused on maintaining kernel access for third-party security software, aiming to reassure stakeholders that their platform remains open to developers despite these challenges.
Emphasis on Security Amid Challenges
Following various security concerns throughout the year, Microsoft is reportedly making strides with the Windows Resiliency Initiative as part of its security strategy. However, discussions reveal that despite a variety of security enhancements being introduced, the company failed to address critical vulnerabilities adequately. The speakers criticize the lack of transparent communication from Microsoft regarding major incidents, specifically referencing the 'incident' surrounding the CrowdStrike hack without naming it directly. There's an ongoing concern about whether the measures being implemented will be sufficient to prevent similar incidents in the future.
Reevaluating Cloud versus On-Premises Strategies
There appears to be a growing realization among organizations that a strictly cloud-based approach may not be suitable for all business needs, leading to a renewed interest in on-premises infrastructure. As companies weigh the costs and benefits of cloud computing against traditional hosting methods, some are finding that it may be more economical to revert to on-premises solutions. This reevaluation is largely driven by actual usage data, with businesses now more equipped to make informed decisions about their IT infrastructures. The discussion captures the sentiment of many who feel compelled to balance between leveraging cloud advantages and maintaining control over their operations.
What does Windows want for Christmas? Richard chats with Paul Thurrott about the crazy year that Windows has had and what 2025 holds. Paul starts with the Ignite keynote that focused on Windows being an open platform - which sounds funny on the surface, but has some logic to it! Security is a key part of that story, which brings up the issues around Crowdstrike and the Secure Future Initiative. And then there's Windows 10 going out of support in 2025 - what choices do you have going forward? Two grumpy old men ring out the year – have a great holiday season!