

Should we vote for all judges?
18 snips Apr 1, 2025
Sierra Juarez, a researcher and fact-checker focusing on Mexican judicial reforms, discusses Mexico's groundbreaking shift to elect judges directly. She delves into President Sheinbaum's aims to boost court integrity while critics argue it threatens judicial independence. The conversation uncovers how these reforms stir anxiety within local and foreign businesses, exploring the delicate balance between public perception and judicial expertise. Juarez highlights potential economic risks linked to this shift, including its impact on investment and credit ratings.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Historical Context of Judicial Reform
- In the 1990s, Mexico's president aimed to professionalize the judiciary.
- Critics argued the system remained elitist, favoring the wealthy and connected.
Motivation Behind Judicial Reform
- Current reforms aim to democratize the judiciary by having judges elected.
- Critics like David Lopez suggest the reforms might be politically motivated.
Lowered Requirements for Judges
- Judge Yasmin Robles-Cortez notes lowered qualification requirements for judges, including Supreme Court justices.
- A three-page essay and references from neighbors or colleagues are now required.