
Books of Titans Podcast #263 - Cratylus by Plato
Oct 10, 2025
Delve into Plato's exploration of language and meaning! Discover the debate between Cratylus, who believes names reflect nature, and Hermogenes, who argues they are socially constructed. Join Socrates as he whimsically guesses the origins of names, revealing insights about concepts like joy and courage. Enjoy thought-provoking discussions on the implications of naming, the flow of words, and how definitions shape our understanding of history. Plus, hear recommendations on translations of this fascinating dialogue!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Names: Nature Or Convention
- Plato's Cratylus frames the debate: are names natural or conventional.
- Socrates investigates whether primary and derivative names are given in accord with nature.
Two Competing Naming Theories
- Cratylus claims each thing has a correct, natural name independent of human agreement.
- Hermogenes argues names arise from social convention and collective agreement.
Etymology As Inquiry, Not Fact
- Socrates treats etymologies as investigative guesses rather than authoritative origins.
- Some of his word-origin speculations illuminate meaning, while others are merely plausible reconstructions.











