Ryan Denton, a Presbyterian minister and church planter from Texas, shares his nuanced views on cessationism and continuationism. He discusses the dangers of a rigid cessationist perspective, emphasizing God's ongoing work in the world. The conversation explores historical interpretations of spiritual gifts, particularly prophecy and tongues, and encourages a thoughtful approach to scripture. They also highlight the importance of discernment in identifying genuine spiritual experiences while advocating for open dialogues among believers.
01:10:28
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Nuanced Cessationism of Reformers
The 16th and 17th century Reformers affirmed cessation of extraordinary offices but acknowledged God's occasional extraordinary operation later on. - This nuanced cessationism allows God to raise apostles, prophets, or evangelists selectively but not to duplicate the original apostolic role.
insights INSIGHT
Risks of Hyper-Cessationism
Hyper-cessationism is a rigid form of cessationism that neglects God's supernatural work beyond apostolic age. - It risks quenching the Spirit and leads to a deistic or anti-supernatural worldview by denying modern extraordinary workings of God.
insights INSIGHT
'Teleos' Means Scripture Completion
The "teleos" (perfection) in 1 Corinthians 13:10 is best understood as the completion of Scripture, not Christ's return. - Illustrations about knowing fully and seeing face to face explain partial to complete, not new personal encounters or revelation.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Andrew Rappaport hosts a compelling discussion with Ryan Denton on the often contentious topic of spiritual gifts, diving into the nuances of continuationism and cessationism. They kick things off by exploring the extremes within these doctrines, particularly focusing on Ryan's concerns regarding the cessationist side, which he believes may sometimes be too rigid. As they navigate through definitions and historical perspectives, they emphasize the importance of balancing scriptural interpretation with a recognition of God's ongoing work in the world. The conversation highlights the value of nuanced understanding, encouraging listeners to engage thoughtfully with both traditional and contemporary views of spiritual gifts. Ultimately, this episode serves as an invitation for open dialogue among believers, stressing the significance of discernment in addressing the complexities of faith and practice.
Takeaways:
The hosts dive deep into the topic of spiritual gifts, discussing continuationism and cessationism, and their nuances, highlighting how these interpretations affect modern Christian practices.
Ryan Denton, a Presbyterian minister, shares his perspective on cessationism, arguing that while certain gifts ceased, God can still work through extraordinary means today, albeit in a non-normative manner.
Andrew Rappaport emphasizes the importance of biblical accuracy in doctrinal discussions, reminding listeners that miracles may occur but should not be confused with the gifts that were present in the apostolic age.
The conversation reveals a mutual respect between the hosts despite their differing views, showcasing how open dialogue can lead to a deeper understanding of complex theological issues.
The hosts stress the significance of discernment in evaluating claims of spiritual experiences, cautioning against attributing personal feelings or experiences as direct communications from God.
Listeners are encouraged to engage with the hosts on future platforms for more discussions, emphasizing the value of respectful debate in theological circles.
Andrew Rappaport's Rapp Report