492. The Jews Who HATE Israel - ex Hasidic Jew Izzy Posen
Dec 12, 2024
auto_awesome
Izzy Posen, a former member of London's Hasidic Jewish community, shares his provocative insights on ultra-Orthodox Judaism and anti-Zionism. He recounts his challenging transition to mainstream society after leaving at 20, exploring the tensions in Jewish identity and political silence within his community. Posen discusses the Hasidic perspective on immigration and its cultural implications, as well as the complex relationships between extremist religious groups and leftist ideologies. His candid views provide a thought-provoking critique of societal dynamics today.
The Satmar sect's anti-Zionist views stem from a religious interpretation of Jewish identity that prioritizes spiritual connection over nationalism.
Leaving the Hasidic community involves facing cultural and language barriers that result in feelings of isolation and challenges in adapting to mainstream society.
Individuals exiting high-control groups often undergo complex identity reconstruction, frequently oscillating between rejecting past ideologies and embracing new worldviews such as extreme liberalism.
Deep dives
Non-Zionist Perspectives in the Hasidic Community
The Hasidic community, particularly the Satmar sect, generally holds a non-Zionist perspective, viewing the rise of Zionism as a significant catastrophe for the Jewish people. The founder of Satmar believed that events such as the Holocaust were divine punishment for the Zionist movement. This anti-Zionist sentiment stems from a traditional religious understanding of Jewish identity, which prioritizes spiritual connection to God over nationalism. Even within certain sects that oppose Zionism, there remains a deep-seated religious connection to the land of Israel, illustrating the complex relationship between faith and politics.
Cultural and Language Barriers Post-Community
Leaving the insular Hasidic community entails profound cultural and language barriers, often leaving individuals feeling isolated in the broader society. The speaker, having grown up speaking Yiddish, had to relearn English; his challenges included navigating social norms that were foreign to him. Upon entering the secular world, he faced difficulties in job interviews due to cultural misunderstandings tied to dress codes and professional behavior. These experiences underline the larger struggle many face when transitioning from closed communities to more diverse environments, where implicit norms and values are often taken for granted.
Identity Reconstruction after Leaving High-Control Groups
Individuals departing high-control groups frequently embark on a complex journey of identity reconstruction. The transition often involves rejecting former ideologies and exploring new worldviews, including a trend towards 'wokeness' or extreme liberalism. This reaction can be seen as a desire to align with groups that reflect freedom from the conservative values they once followed. However, the process is nuanced, with many individuals finding themselves oscillating between different ideologies as they seek to define their new identity in a broader societal context.
Political Maneuvering and Identity within the Hasidic Community
The Hasidic community generally practices a form of political intercession, preferring to remain loyal to those in power rather than voicing criticism. This approach stems from a historical context where Jews often found it more feasible to secure community needs through relationships with influential figures rather than engaging in direct political confrontation. The speaker highlights a disconnect between Hasidic individuals and mainstream political issues, particularly during the rise of figures like Jeremy Corbyn. Their focus remains on preserving their communities and education systems, rather than integrating into broader political discourses.
Concerns over Immigration and Societal Cohesion
Concerns around immigration reflect apprehension about societal cohesion and economic impacts, particularly as large numbers of newcomers come from varying cultural backgrounds. The speaker emphasizes that the integration of immigrants is crucial for maintaining a stable society, where shared values and language play fundamental roles. He warns of the potential long-term drain on the economy by new arrivals who do not contribute productively. By advocating for transparency in immigration policies and a selective approach, he argues for a need to uphold the social contract, which relies on mutual contribution between the state and its citizens.
Izzy Posen is a former member of the Hasidic Jewish community in London. He tells me about the extreme sects of Haredi Judaism who hate Israel. He also discusses mass immigration and other current topics.