In this thought-provoking discussion, journalist Anne Applebaum, historian David Frum, and reporters Barton Gellman and George Packer examine the precarious state of American democracy. They dive into the impact of misinformation from the 2020 election and the Capitol attack on January 6th, 2021. The group highlights the urgent need for electoral reforms, the growing threats of extremism, and the role civic education plays in nurturing future democratic engagement. Their insights paint a vivid picture of democracy's crossroads and the power of informed discourse.
Republican officeholders fear losing power by not aligning with Trump's base.
Top Republicans prioritize power over upholding norms, leading to corruption.
Trump's rise shifted GOP towards authoritarianism and loyalty above governance.
Despite ethical concerns, Trump's presidency maintained traditional Republican policies.
Republicans' shift against fair elections allows for subverting democracy and undermining trust in institutions.
Deep dives
Incentives Driving Republican Support for Trump
Many Republican officeholders supported Trump out of opportunism and fear, responding to incentives driven by the base's support for Trump and the fear of losing their seats if they don't align with him. The threat of primary challenges and Trump's influence over constituents shape the behavior of most elected officials.
Normalization of Unethical Behavior in the Republican Party
The top of the Republican Party has shifted towards power for its own sake, leading to a corruption of power with a focus on maintaining power and control rather than upholding norms and laws. The base of the party has become increasingly populist, distrusting mainstream institutions and fostering a culture that views any defiance against Trump as career-ending.
Trump's Path to Nomination and Growth of Populist Base
Trump's rise in the 2015 Republican primary was initially seen as a means to weaken Jeb Bush, leading to a chain reaction where Trump gained support and other Republicans deferred to him as Jeb Bush's challenger. The base's disillusionment with traditional institutions and the party's shift towards authoritarianism were major factors in Trump's consolidation of power.
Impact of Trump's Presidency on the Republican Party
Trump's presidency fundamentally altered the Republican Party, leading to a focus on loyalty to Trump over principled governance. While Trump's actions were often unethical and challenged norms, they did not significantly alter policy outcomes, as he operated within a conventional Republican agenda with few substantial accomplishments.
Impact of Trump's Power Post-Election Loss
Despite losing the election, Trump's power was maintained through his influence on a large base of supporters. Many Republicans continued to support him, believing in the false claim that he had not lost. Trump's power lay in his control over public sentiment, rather than policy programs.
Challenges in Upholding Democratic Values
By November 2020, many Republicans had shifted away from valuing fair elections and majority rule, making it easier for them to support efforts that subverted democracy. Attempts to undermine faith in the system, including media and institutions confirming election results, were seen as advantageous for certain political gains.
Concerns Over Election Subversion and Guardrail Establishment
Efforts to uproot obstacles to Trump's attempt to overturn the election were witnessed, indicating a strategy to ensure favorable electoral outcomes. Legal challenges were countered with strategic political maneuvers, presenting potential threats to future elections. Reforms to address election subversion, such as amending the Electoral Count Act, were discussed to safeguard democratic processes.
Concerns about the impact of social media on fear, anger, and tribalism in communities
The discussion highlights the challenge of addressing fear, anger, and tribalism in communities in a way that allows for open-mindedness and critical thinking. Social media is identified as a significant contributor to this issue by perpetuating the spread of emotional and divisive content, often based on false information. The conversation also delves into the role of big tech platforms in deciding what content to promote or censor, emphasizing the complexities of balancing free speech with responsible platform governance.
Exploring the need for potential changes to democracy and the role of technology in shaping public discourse
The conversation touches on the possibility of reevaluating democracy's efficacy in modern society and the need for new mechanisms to address evolving challenges. The impact of algorithms in shaping online discourse is highlighted, with an emphasis on the need to regulate algorithms to promote constructive conversations and consensus-building. The discussion also reflects on the changing landscape of politics, emphasizing the importance of focusing on policy discussions rather than identity-based politics to foster a more functional democratic process.
Sam Harris speaks with Anne Applebaum, David Frum, Barton Gellman, and George Packer about the ongoing threat to American democracy posed by Republican misinformation and disinformation regarding the 2020 Presidential Election and the attack on the Capitol on January 6th, 2021.
If the Making Sense podcast logo in your player is BLACK, you can SUBSCRIBE to gain access to all full-length episodes at samharris.org/subscribe.
Learning how to train your mind is the single greatest investment you can make in life. That’s why Sam Harris created the Waking Up app. From rational mindfulness practice to lessons on some of life’s most important topics, join Sam as he demystifies the practice of meditation and explores the theory behind it.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
