77: Robert Pirsig’s Zen & the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance
Nov 28, 2023
auto_awesome
The podcast discusses Robert Pirsig's Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, examining his philosophical ideas on quality, the dichotomy between classical and romantic approaches, and the criticism of science and Aristotelian traditions. It also explores the concept of quality shaping our world, the reevaluation of reality, and the importance of committing to what we care about.
Robert Pirsig's novel challenges common sense intuitions and dogmas in Western philosophy, emphasizing the importance of reconciling dualistic and non-dualistic modes of thought.
Pirsig explores the tension between classical and romantic modes of life through the lens of motorcycle maintenance, highlighting the significance of understanding the underlying structure and mechanics.
Pirsig delves into the concept of quality, proposing that it stimulates the creation of our reality and advocating for its prioritization in education and personal pursuits.
Deep dives
The Naming Trick of Zen in the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance
Robert Persig's novel is named as an homage to Heracles' Zen in the Art of Archery, but the content of the book is very different. It is primarily an autobiographical account of a motorcycle road trip through the Western United States. Zen Buddhism is only loosely discussed, while the book focuses more on challenging common sense intuitions and dogmas in Western philosophy.
Persig's Critique of Aristotelianism and the Dualistic Divide
Persig critiques the Aristotelian tradition for perpetuating a divide between philosophy and natural philosophy, substance and form. He argues that this divide has led to a fragmented understanding of reality and a neglect of the quality in both rhetoric and the pursuit of truth. Persig seeks to reconcile the dualistic and non-dualistic modes of thought, aiming for a unity that transcends rigid categorizations.
The Classic vs. Romantic Tension in Motorcycle Maintenance
Persig explores the tension between the classical and romantic modes of life through the lens of motorcycle maintenance. He contrasts the Sutherlands, who approach their motorcycles from a romantic perspective, with Persig himself, who takes a classical approach. Persig emphasizes the importance of understanding the underlying structure and mechanics of the motorcycle, and how this understanding enhances enjoyment and mastery.
Persig's Concept of Quality and its Metaphysical Significance
Persig delves into his concept of quality, which he sees as an event that occurs when the subject becomes aware of the object. Quality is not merely subjective or objective, but rather a meeting point between the two. Persig argues that quality precedes the subject-object split and is the foundation for awareness. He rephrases his argument in terms of stimulus-response theory to address skepticism and highlights the importance of quality in the realm of rhetoric and human experience.
The Quest for Quality and Excellence
Robert Piersig explores the concept of quality and argues that it stimulates the creation of our reality. He believes that quality is the driving force behind our motivation and education. Piersig proposes that grades and meaningless hurdles in education should be eliminated, allowing individuals to pursue their own paths and discover the most quality in their lives. He draws a parallel between his theory of quality and Nietzsche's concept of value, emphasizing the importance of valuing and caring as essential components of quality.
The Sophists vs. Socrates and Plato
Piersig delves into the conflict between the sophists, who believe in the relativity of truth, and Socrates and Plato, who defend absolute truth. He argues that Plato encapsulates the concept of Erate, personal excellence, and transforms it into a rigid and immortal idea, while the sophists view Erate as a pragmatic pursuit of personal virtue. Piersig challenges the dichotomy created by Plato, asserting that rhetoric, when properly used, expresses authenticity and creativity. He suggests that valuing personal excellence and pursuing quality in every endeavor is crucial to recapturing Erate in modern life.
Today we continue with our inquiry into rhetoric and dialectic, with Robert Pirsig’s Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. Pirsig, like Nietzsche, saw himself as a modern-day Sophist, and part of his work was the rescue of the Sophistic school from the ill repute visited upon them by the Socratics. Perhaps more expansively, Pirsig devotes his philosophical work to the question, “What is quality?”, drawing on the Greek concept of arete, or excellence. His philosophical ideas do not come to us through a dispassionate treatise, however, but through an autobiographical novel. Pirsig was treated with electroshock therapy, leaving him with a new personality, and the feeling that the person he once was is dead: he merely happens to carry the blurry memories of another man. While on a motorcycle trip with his son, Pirsig struggles to unify the dichotomy between classical and romantic, between substance and form, between the two personalities within himself, and between himself and his son. This work remains one of the most important philosophical contributions to American literature in the 20th century, and hopefully today I can show all of you why this work of “pop philosophy” is one of my favorite books, and one to which I regularly return.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode