The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Josh Allen OUTDUELS Tua, Bills Take Down Dolphins on TNF
Sep 19, 2025
John Middlekauff, a former NFL scout, shares insights on the Bills' impressive win over the Dolphins, defending coach Mike McDaniel's status despite Miami's 0-3 start. He discusses the challenges backup quarterbacks face and presents his takes on the controversial Tush Push and Tom Brady narratives. Joining him is Stuckey from The Action Network, who highlights key betting angles for the upcoming weekend in both college and NFL matchups, offering valuable insights for bettors looking to capitalize on underdog plays.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Defending McDaniel Against 'Nerd' Label
- Middlekauff recalls Rex Ryan calling Mike McDaniel a "nerd" and pushes back on that simplistic take.
- He frames McDaniel as an elite offensive schemer who elevates average quarterbacks like Tua.
Good Coach, Bad Fit In Miami
- Mike McDaniel is a top offensive mind but likely out of his depth as a head coach in Miami's dysfunctional roster environment.
- John Middlekauff argues McDaniel will thrive again as a coordinator if relieved of head coaching duties.
Josh Allen Creates Wins Singlehandedly
- Josh Allen is a transcendent talent who frequently wins by creating explosive plays rather than relying on a dominant defense.
- Middlekauff sees the Bills as perennial AFC favorites if they get timely turnovers and stay relatively healthy.