The podcast discusses query optimization in PostgreSQL, including steps involved, testing in a similar setup as production, analyzing the impact of sampling and bloat, optimizing queries' impact on other queries, and extreme indexing failure cases.
To test optimization ideas effectively, it is crucial to replicate the production environment as closely as possible, including data, statistics, and query settings, and consider the impact on other queries and stability.
To holistically assess optimization changes, it is necessary to compare the performance before and after the change, monitor metrics like hot updates and index performance, estimate potential overhead, and use a combination of manual analysis, reactive approaches, and automated testing tools.
Deep dives
Verifying Optimization Ideas
To verify optimization ideas, it is important to test queries in a similar setup as the production environment. This involves ensuring the same data, statistics, and query settings are used. Achieving the same plan behavior on a non-production environment can be challenging, but there are specific tricks that can help, such as exporting and importing statistics or using tools like hypothetical indexes and partitions. It is crucial to ensure that the optimization ideas not only improve the targeted query but also do not negatively impact other queries or introduce instability.
Challenges of Testing in a Similar Environment
While testing in a similar environment is beneficial, it can be problematic due to issues like data access and privacy. Giving developers access to production data can raise security concerns and lead to instability. Logical copies of production data can be used for testing, but care must be taken to ensure that the plan behavior remains the same. Factors like differences in rel pages, insert order, and buffer numbers can affect the planner's behavior and outcome. Despite these challenges, it is still important to aim for as close a resemblance to the production environment as possible when testing optimization ideas.
Holistic Testing and Approving Optimization Changes
To holistically test and approve optimization changes, it is necessary to consider various factors. Direct comparisons before and after the optimization change can showcase the improvement in the targeted query. However, it is equally important to assess the potential impact on other queries. This can involve monitoring metrics like hot updates, re-evaluating index performance overhead, and estimating any introduced right overhead. While fully automated testing tools may be challenging to develop, a reactive approach of reviewing code, discussing potential effects, and monitoring performance can still be useful. Additionally, testing queries from production and running experiments on shared environments can help identify any regressions or improvements. Overall, a combination of manual analysis, reactive approaches, and automated testing tools can aid in testing optimization changes.
What did you like or not like? What should we discuss next time? Let us know by tweeting us on @PostgresFM or by commenting on our topic ideas Google doc.
If you would like to share this episode, here's a good link (and thank you!)