Mike Pesca, a veteran journalist and creator of 'The Gist', critiques legacy media’s commitment to objectivity. He reflects on his controversial exit from Slate and discusses how NPR's shift towards progressive moral clarity alienates traditional audiences. The conversation explores why leading newspapers are struggling and the challenges of misinformation in today’s landscape. Pesca emphasizes the importance of nuanced discussions in independent journalism, advocating for exposure to diverse ideas to counteract the decline of critical debate.
Mike Pesca critiques legacy media for sacrificing objectivity and fairness in favor of progressive agendas, undermining journalistic integrity.
He highlights how the shift to subscription models and the rise of podcasts have redefined audience expectations and media consumption habits.
Pesca reflects on his experiences at Slate, revealing a stifling of diverse ideas that ultimately prompted his departure from the organization.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Media Critique
Mike Peska emphasizes the need for a more critical view of legacy media, highlighting its drift from objectivity in pursuit of progressive goals. He reflects on his controversial defense of a New York Times reporter for using the n-word in a contextually sensitive discussion, illustrating how media discussions have changed. Peska notes that many media organizations are struggling with their credibility as they shift their focus towards mandatory diversity agendas, sometimes at the expense of quality programming. This creates a challenge in maintaining a balance between diverse perspectives and the core objective of informative journalism.
Failures and Adaptations in Journalism
Peska discusses the failing newspapers and their inability to adapt to evolving media consumption habits, particularly in the face of growing podcast and digital content. He argues that while NPR once dominated the podcast scene, up-and-coming shows like The Daily have taken talent and reshaped audience expectations. The shift from advertising revenue to subscription models has also affected the type of content produced, leading to a decline in viewers seeking traditional news coverage. This evolution reflects broader changes in media consumption, where the demand for engaging and thought-provoking content surpasses the known channels of communication.
The Role of Slates in Journalism
During his tenure at Slate, Peska observed a marked change in the editorial stance as the media landscape shifted post-2016 election. He experienced firsthand how the organization became less welcoming to diverse ideas and began to overlook engaging in discourse that challenged prevailing ideologies. He believes that the emphasis on not giving platforms to controversial ideas stifled the once vibrant exchange of opinions that characterized the publication. Ultimately, this led to his departure from Slate, as a changing environment made it increasingly difficult to maintain the critical standards he valued.
Market Influences on News Media
The discussion also touches on the changing landscape of newspaper economics and its effect on journalistic integrity. Peska asserts that many legacy newspapers, like the Philadelphia Inquirer, have compromised their engaging content in favor of ideological alignment, which has contributed to declining readership. He highlights that while some outlets such as Bloomberg and the Wall Street Journal maintain their credibility, many others have lost touch with broader audience expectations. The author's evaluation reinforces the idea that financial viability and engaging storytelling are key elements that need to be prioritized in crafting modern journalism.
Redefining Objectivity in Journalism
Peska argues for a re-examination of the concept of objectivity in modern journalism, indicating that the current approach often lacks a genuine attempt at neutrality. He acknowledges that while there may be a diversity of voices in the media today, there is a risk of fragmenting into echo chambers where dissenting opinions are disregarded, hindering productive discourse. By reflecting on his experiences and observations, he suggests the need for a balance between maintaining credibility and engaging with a wider range of viewpoints. The ongoing debate around misinformation and its implications on public discourse further complicates the mission for journalists striving to uphold standards of fairness and accuracy.
Today's guest is Mike Pesca, who publishes The Gist podcast every weekday. The Gist, which launched in 2014, is a tight 30 minutes of news, interviews, and opinions on the biggest issues of the day. Pesca is a veteran of NPR and Slate—experiences that have made him an outspoken critic of legacy media, especially its willingness to overthrow longstanding commitments to objectivity and fairness in pursuit of progressive versions of "moral clarity."
Reason's Nick Gillespie talks with him about his controversial 2021 separation from Slate after he defended a New York Times reporter's use of a racial slur, why once-vaunted newspapers such as The Washington Post and the Los Angeles Times are rightly losing readers and money, and whether the old world of three broadcast TV networks and heavily gate-kept media had any value.
Today's sponsors:
Lumen. Lumen is the world's first handheld metabolic coach. You just breathe into the device and it measures your metabolism through your breath. The phone-based app lets you know if you're burning fat or carbs, and it gives you tailored guidance to improve your nutrition, workouts, sleep, and even stress management. Your metabolism is your body's engine—it's how your body turns the food you eat into fuel that keeps you going. Because your metabolism is at the center of everything your body does, optimal metabolic health translates to a bunch of benefits, including easier weight management, improved energy levels, better fitness results, and better sleep. It can help women track their cycles and the onset of menopause, and adjust recommendations to keep your metabolism healthy through hormonal shifts. Take the next step in improving your health: Go to lumen.me/INTERVIEW to get 15 percent of your purchase.
The Reason Speakeasy: The Reason Speakeasy is a monthly, unscripted conversation in New York City with outspoken defenders of free thinking and heterodoxy that doubles as a live taping of The Reason Interview With Nick Gillespie. The next event is scheduled for Wednesday, September 11, and features Fox News' Kat Timpf, whose new book is I Used To Like You Until…(How Binary Thinking Divides Us). Tickets are $15 and include beer, wine, soft drinks, and food. Go here for details.