Iran-Israel: Brink Of War? w/Norman Finkelstein & Benny Morris
Aug 9, 2024
auto_awesome
Norman Finkelstein, a renowned political scientist and author, and Benny Morris, an influential historian, engage in a heated debate over the escalating tensions between Iran and Israel. They discuss the implications of the assassination of Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh, with Finkelstein and Morris presenting starkly contrasting views. The conversation delves into historical grievances, Iran's potential military retaliation, and the alarming consideration of Israel resorting to nuclear power as the conflict intensifies.
Former Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett argues that Iran is the primary aggressor in the Israel-Iran conflict, posing existential threats to Israel.
The podcast highlights the ethical concerns over the high civilian toll in Gaza amidst Israel's military operations against Hamas, raising questions about military conduct.
Deep dives
Instacart's Summer Delivery Service
Instacart emphasizes the convenience of grocery delivery services available throughout summer, ensuring that customers can enjoy their favorite snacks and drinks delivered rapidly, often within just 30 minutes. The promotion includes offers such as free delivery on the first three orders, encouraging new users to engage with their platform. This service aims to elevate the delivery experience, making it as swift as traditional room service but without the wait. The advertisement positions Instacart as a key player in making summer entertaining and hassle-free, catering to the needs of hungry customers.
Israeli-Iranian Geopolitical Tensions
The episode addresses the long-standing conflict between Israel and Iran, where the current Israeli Prime Minister, Naftali Bennett, argues that Iran has been aggressively pursuing a strategy to create chaos in the Middle East through proxy groups. He asserts that Israel has a duty to respond to threats from Iran and its affiliates like Hamas and Hezbollah, considering them existential dangers. Bennett believes that for peace, the Iranian regime must be completely dismantled, likening it to the Soviet Union's dissolution, predicting eventual democratic governance in Iran. He emphasizes the need for unwavering military action against these threats to ensure Israel's security and that of the West.
Civilian Casualties and Warfare Conduct
The discussion revolves around the high civilian toll in Gaza as Israel continues its military operations against Hamas, raising ethical concerns about the intensity of Israel's response. Israeli leaders maintain that their actions are necessary for national defense against aggressive enemies aiming for Israel's destruction, which justifies their military strategies. Critics argue that the deaths of tens of thousands, including many civilians, reveal a troubling aspect of military conduct and might invite international backlash. The reality on the ground highlights the complexity of warfare where civilian lives become collateral damage amid efforts to combat terrorism.
The Future of Gaza Post-Conflict
As the conflict rages on, questions about the future of Gaza and its governance arise, particularly after a potential military victory over Hamas. Naftali Bennett insists that once Hamas is defeated, responsible local leadership should be identified to govern Gaza, emphasizing the necessity of preventing a resurgence of militant control. He envisions international assistance, primarily from Gulf nations and Egypt, to help rebuild Gaza's infrastructure after the conflict. However, concerns about who will oversee Gaza in the aftermath of violence and how to manage the considerable displacement of civilians remain pivotal in discussions about the region's long-term stability.
The world collectively holds its breath as it awaits a massive attack on Israel is anticipated by the Islamic Republic of Iran. This comes after the assassination of Hamas political leader Ismail Haniyeh in the Iranian capital city of Tehran. The international consensus is that the conflict between the two countries is going to get much much worse.
Piers Morgan brings together veritable experts on the region; speaking first to former Prime Minister of Israel Naftali Bennett. Naftali puts the blame for the violence squarely on the shoulders of Iran, and says Israel’s efforts indirectly defend the West from harm. Then, Piers moderates a blazing row between political scientist Norman Finkelstein and Israeli historian Benny Morris. The two trade barbed words over what the assassination of Haniyeh and what it could lead to. The most frightening contention; that Israel may resort to nuclear weaponry.