Michael Rembis, "Writing Mad Lives in the Age of the Asylum" (Oxford UP, 2025)
Feb 9, 2025
auto_awesome
Michael Rembis, a Professor of History at the University at Buffalo and director of the Center for Disability Studies, sheds light on the often-overlooked narratives of asylum inmates between 1830 and 1950. He discusses how their writings reveal the harsh realities of life in asylums, challenging the stigma surrounding madness. Rembis highlights the activism of former inmates who fought for reforms against oppressive lunacy laws, emphasizing the importance of their voices in understanding mental health history and advocating for change.
The podcast emphasizes the powerful impact of mad writers' narratives on reshaping the historical understanding of madness beyond conventional medical perspectives.
It highlights the communal strength and support networks formed among asylum inmates, which were crucial for navigating mental distress and pushing for reforms.
Deep dives
Embracing Authenticity in Dating
The discussion highlights a new approach to dating that encourages individuals to be more authentic rather than conforming to superficial norms. Listeners are urged to express their true selves, such as sharing personal playlists, including show tunes, as a way to connect more meaningfully with potential matches. This shift towards intentional dating reflects a growing understanding of personal desires and preferences, paving the way for more genuine connections. The message is clear: being unapologetically oneself is not only liberating but also attractive to others.
Intersection of Madness and Writing
The research emphasizes the significance of mad writers and their narratives in understanding the history of madness, often overlooked in traditional histories that focus on institutional perspectives. By examining various forms of writing such as pamphlets and memoirs, the findings reveal the personal experiences of those labeled as mad, challenging the dominant narratives constructed by medical professionals. This shift changes the lens through which madness is viewed, offering a more nuanced perspective that highlights the voices and experiences of individuals within institutions. Such storytelling not only sheds light on their struggles but also validates their lived experiences as critical historical sources.
Violence in the Asylum System
The analysis reveals the complex relationship between violence and the asylum system, illustrating how those labeled as mad were often painted as violent individuals despite evidence suggesting otherwise. It emphasizes that, in reality, mad individuals have frequently been victims of violence rather than perpetrators, countering the stereotype often associated with them. The narrative examines how the expansion of asylums in the 19th century was influenced by societal fears and misconceptions about madness, ultimately leading to systemic violence against those within these institutions. Furthermore, it sheds light on how these experiences of violence became avenues for mad writers to articulate their resistance and resilience.
Community and Support Among Mad Writers
The exploration of relationships and mutual aid among mad writers demonstrates the profound connections formed through shared experiences in asylums. Many individuals forged deep relationships that not only helped them endure the hardships of institutional life but also inspired collective efforts towards reform after their release. These bonds often transcended class and racial lines, highlighting a communal strength among marginalized individuals. As a result, the formation of support networks laid the groundwork for future advocacy and recovery movements, illustrating the critical role of community in navigating mental distress and societal reintegration.
The asylum--at once a place of refuge, incarceration, and abuse--touched the lives of many Americans living between 1830 and 1950. What began as a few scattered institutions in the mid-eighteenth century grew to 579 public and private asylums by the 1940s. About one out of every 280 Americans was an inmate in an asylum at an annual cost to taxpayers of approximately $200 million.
Using the writing of former asylum inmates, as well as other sources, Writing Mad Lives in the Age of the Asylum(Oxford UP, 2025) reveals a history of madness and the asylum that has remained hidden by a focus on doctors, diagnoses, and other interventions into mad people's lives. Although those details are present in this story, its focus is the hundreds of inmates who spoke out or published pamphlets, memorials, memoirs, and articles about their experiences. They recalled physical beatings and prolonged restraint and isolation. They described what it felt like to be gawked at like animals by visitors and the hardships they faced re-entering the community. Many inmates argued that asylums were more akin to prisons than medical facilities and testified before state legislatures and the US Congress, lobbying for reforms to what became popularly known as "lunacy laws."
Michael Rembis demonstrates how their stories influenced popular, legal, and medical conceptualizations of madness and the asylum at a time when most Americans seemed to be groping toward a more modern understanding of the many different forms of "insanity." The result is a clearer sense of the role of mad people and their allies in shaping one of the largest state expenditures in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries--and, at the same time, a recovery of the social and political agency of these vibrant and dynamic "mad writers."