Honestly with Bari Weiss What Jordan Neely’s Death Tells Us About Mental Illness and Vigilantism
6 snips
Jun 7, 2023 
Join Jonathan Rosen, author of "The Best Minds," Kat Rosenfield, novelist and columnist, and Rafael Mangual, legal policy expert, as they unpack the tragedy of Jordan Neely's death. The discussion dives into the societal failures surrounding mental health and public safety, exploring vigilante responses and the complexities of perceived threats in urban environments. They reflect on how systemic issues contribute to such crises and the urgent need for compassionate policy solutions that bridge the gap between mental health care and societal responsibility.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Subway Intervention Discrepancy
- Rafael Mangual recalls a subway incident where a man accosted a woman.
- Bystanders were criticized for not intervening, highlighting conflicting public expectations.
Psychosis: Not a Break, but a Shift
- Jonathan Rosen emphasizes that psychosis is not simply a break but a shift from reality.
- This detachment affects decision-making abilities, necessitating external intervention.
Systemic Failure vs. Inevitability
- Kat Rosenfield questions whether the system's failure is solely responsible for Jordan Neely's situation.
- She notes Neely's extensive history of interactions with the system, suggesting an element of inevitability.
