Justin Trudeau’s Ominous Online Harms Act: ‘Minority Report’ Comes to Canada
Jun 14, 2024
auto_awesome
Conor Friedersdorf discusses Trudeau's Online Harms Act, which allows punishment for future actions. They delve into extreme provisions like life sentences for advocating genocide, sparking concerns about free speech and governmental control.
The Online Harms Act allows punishment for anticipated hate speech, raising concerns about free speech threats.
The concept of pre-crime is introduced, questioning the constitutionality and potential misuse of the legislation.
Deep dives
Canada's Online Harms Act and Free Speech Threats
The podcast discusses Canada's Online Harms Act, a concerning bill that has raised alarm regarding free speech threats. The bill allows the government to imprison individuals for promoting genocidal hate speech, even without the speech being uttered yet. Justin Trudeau's government faces criticism, including from novelist Margaret Atwood, for the extreme provisions that could lead to imprisoning individuals based on anticipated hate speech.
Constitutional Concerns and Pre-Crime Measures
The summary raises constitutional concerns about the Online Harms Act, highlighting its conflict with free speech principles, especially in comparison to the US First Amendment. The discussion delves into the concept of pre-crime, where individuals could face penalties for future speech, raising questions about the law's constitutionality and potential misuse by authorities.
Implications for Civil Liberties and Government Power
The summary addresses the broader implications of the Online Harms Act on civil liberties and government power. It criticizes the draconian nature of the proposed legislation, emphasizing how it could impact marginalized and immigrant communities disproportionately. The conversation reflects on the potential consequences of such extreme measures on free speech and the need for critical evaluation of legislative impacts.
Quillette podcast host Jonathan Kay talks to Atlantic Magazine staff writer Conor Friedersdorf about an alarmingly censorious government bill that would allow officials to punish Canadians for things they haven’t done yet.