Yoni Appelbaum, deputy executive editor of The Atlantic and author of "Stuck: How the Privileged and the Propertied Broke the Engine of American Opportunity," joins the conversation to address declining American mobility and its effects. He discusses how zoning laws and regulatory frameworks stifle small businesses and social mobility. Yoni also explores the paradox of rootedness versus the need for geographic movement. Their engaging dialogue provides a fresh perspective on how America can revitalize its promise of opportunity.
The sharp decline in American mobility over the decades has profound implications for societal engagement and economic opportunity.
Zoning laws, originally intended to manage urban growth, have become restrictive tools that exacerbate the housing crisis and inhibit social mobility.
Policy reforms that facilitate housing development and relocation are crucial for restoring individual agency and fostering economic growth in America.
Deep dives
The Decline of American Mobility
American mobility has sharply declined over the past several decades, with only one in thirteen Americans moving annually, down from one in five in 1970. This decline has significant societal implications, as mobility has historically fostered economic opportunity and social dynamism. The podcast highlights that this stagnation affects not only individual lives but also the overall economy, leading to a less involved and more divided society. The drop in mobility is a long-term trend that has persisted across various economic conditions and political administrations.
Impacts of Zoning Legislation
Zoning laws, initially designed to separate land uses and manage urban growth, have evolved into tools that restrict housing availability and social mobility. These regulations often prevent new construction in desirable areas, exacerbating the housing crisis and limiting opportunities for those who wish to move. The podcast emphasizes that this has led to a disconnection between where jobs are found and where affordable housing exists, trapping individuals in stagnant communities. As a result, zoning has become a major barrier to economic mobility and a contributing factor to rising inequality.
The Sociological Effects of Mobility
The podcast discusses how mobility contributes to community engagement and social cohesion by exposing individuals to diverse perspectives and experiences. When people move, they bring new ideas and social interactions, which foster cooperation and reduce isolation. Conversely, the lack of mobility results in increased polarization, with communities becoming more homogenous and entrenched in their beliefs. This stagnation can lead to a sense of cynicism and disconnection from broader societal progress, as individuals become more focused on local grievances.
Opportunities for Policy Change
The conversation stresses the need for policy reforms that encourage housing development and facilitate mobility. Innovative public policy could help dismantle existing barriers by providing support for individuals seeking to relocate for better opportunities. Programs could include housing vouchers, information on relocation options, and initiatives designed to ease the transition for families moving to areas with more economic potential. The goal is to restore the fundamental principle of choice, allowing individuals the freedom to seek improved circumstances by moving to places where they can thrive.
Challenging Conventional Wisdom
The podcast critiques commonly held assumptions about American society, particularly regarding mobility and opportunity. It argues that many progressives have inadvertently crafted a regulatory environment that stifles growth and perpetuates inequality. By recognizing the impacts of historical policies and their unintended consequences, there is potential for a paradigm shift in how society approaches these issues. The discussion encourages a reevaluation of regulatory frameworks with the aim of promoting agency and revitalizing the American dream for future generations.
Yoni Appelbaum, deputy executive editor of The Atlantic, makes his Remnant debut to discuss his new book, Stuck: How the Privileged and the Propertied Broke the Engine of American Opportunity. Jonah Goldberg and Yoni discuss America's unique social and geographic mobility, the tricky history of tenements, and the dirty laundry of zoning.
The Remnant is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including Jonah’s G-File newsletter, regular livestreams, and other members-only content—click here.
