Peter Adamson, Professor of Philosophy, discusses the diverse interpretations of Plato's work, delving into his role as an esoteric writer and the contrasting writing styles of Plato and Aristotle. They explore the authenticity of Plato's letters, the irony in his writing, and his use of myths and cosmological accounts.
Plato's works can be interpreted in multiple ways, leading to different 'Platos' based on factors such as historical context, literary interests, and philosophical biases.
Both analytic and esoteric interpretations of Plato emphasize the need for intellectual engagement and recognition that understanding Plato requires more than a surface-level reading.
Deep dives
Different interpretations of Plato's works
Plato's works can be interpreted in various ways, leading to the perception of multiple 'Platos.' Some depict him as primarily engaged in logical argumentation, while others emphasize his use of mythological stories and enigmatic language. These differing interpretations are influenced by factors such as historical context, literary interests, and philosophical biases. It is essential to recognize that Plato's dialogues can be seen as literary works that aim to provoke thought and explore complex philosophical concepts.
Both analytic and esoteric interpretations of Plato's dialogues emphasize the need for intellectual engagement. Analytic philosophers delve into the dialogues, striving to uncover hidden premises, extract implicit arguments, or even identify intentional flaws in Plato's reasoning. Esoteric readers, on the other hand, search for deeper meanings that may transcend the surface level of the text. While the motivations and approaches differ between these interpretations, they share the idea that understanding Plato requires more than a surface-level reading.
The notion of esotericism in Plato's works
The idea that Plato's dialogues hold esoteric or hidden meanings has captivated scholars throughout history. Plato's use of cryptic references, structural devices, and even mythical tales has led many to consider him an esoteric writer. While interpretations of esotericism in Plato's works vary, they often suggest that he intended to convey teachings accessible only to a select group or invite readers to dig deeper beneath the surface. However, it is important to distinguish between interpretations that seek hidden meanings within the dialogues themselves and interpretations that rely on external, additional sources to unlock Plato's message.
Plato's writing style and the nature of his philosophy
Plato's dialogues exhibit a complex and sophisticated writing style that combines philosophical arguments with literary elements. His use of myths, frame narratives, and rhetorical devices reflects a deliberate attempt to engage readers and explore philosophical questions from different angles. While some may view the inclusion of myths as non-philosophical or merely decorative, it is crucial to recognize that Plato himself considered these elements as integral parts of his philosophical project. Thus, the study of Plato's philosophy should encompass both the explicit arguments presented in the dialogues and the literary techniques employed to convey his ideas.
We discuss Plato with Peter Adamson, Professor of Philosophy at the LMU in Munich and presenter of the History of Philosophy Podcast, asking the question: how can the Plato of analytic philosophy be the same man as the esoteric Plato?
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode