Randall Kennedy on Harvard Protests, Antisemitism, and the Meaning of Free Speech
May 6, 2024
auto_awesome
Harvard law professor Randall Kennedy discusses the climate of antisemitism on campuses and the fallout from recent events. He addresses the lawsuit against Harvard equating opposition to Zionism with antisemitism, highlighting the danger of rendering certain thinkers unteachable. The podcast explores the complex truths amidst protests, criticisms, and swift condemnations within university settings, and the challenges of regulating speech related to antisemitism and racism at universities.
Criticism of Harvard president was politically motivated, disguised as combating antisemitism.
Lawsuit equating Zionism opposition with antisemitism threatens academic freedom and education diversity.
Deep dives
Controversy over Anti-Semitism on College Campuses
The eruption of protest on college campuses, particularly at Harvard University, has raised concerns about anti-Semitism. College leaders faced hearings in Congress over this issue, with some viewing the situation as a partisan political cause.
Challenges Faced by University Presidents During Congressional Hearings
University presidents were criticized for their responses during the congressional hearings, with conflicting views on their preparation and actions. Academic leaders like Claudine Gay faced scrutiny for their handling of student reactions and statements about sensitive issues like the Hamas attack.
Debate on Freedom of Speech and Campus Environment
The podcast delves into the complex balance between freedom of speech and creating a safe environment for free inquiry on campuses like Harvard. Legal definitions of anti-Semitism and racist speech are discussed, highlighting the challenges in navigating these boundaries within the university setting and addressing concerns about possible infringements on academic freedom.
In December, the presidents of three universities were summoned to Congress for hearings about whether a climate of antisemitism exists on campuses. Politicians like Elise Stefanik made headlines, and two of the presidents, including Harvard’s Claudine Gay, were soon out of their posts. The Harvard law professor Randall Kennedy wrote an essay for the London Review of Books about the reverberations of those events. “Folks were out to get Claudine Gay from the get-go,” he thinks, “and were going to use any openings with which to do that”—for reasons that had little to do with protecting Jews. Kennedy tells David Remnick about a lawsuit against Harvard that would equate opposition to Zionism with antisemitism, and render a range of thinkers (including many Jews) unteachable. And “this,” Kennedy asserts, “is very dangerous.”
This segment is part of the New Yorker Radio Hour’s episode devoted to the protests and the speech issues that college campuses have raised.