Advisory Opinions The Future of Free Speech
28 snips
Oct 14, 2025 Sarah Isgur and David French engage in a lively discussion on threats to free speech, examining a Ball State employee's firing over social media posts. They delve into NYU's struggles with controversial speakers and the implications of 'jawboning' by the government. The duo explores anti-SLAPP laws, potential reforms for civic education, and the need for transparency in government communications. They emphasize that protecting free speech goes beyond legal measures, requiring cultural support and renewal.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Private Post Led To Firing
- A Ball State administrator posted on her private Facebook criticizing Charlie Kirk and lost her job after the post went viral.
- David French says she would likely win a First Amendment lawsuit because it was private speech by a public employee.
Pre-Crime Logic Drives Prophylactic Firings
- Administrators preemptively fire employees citing assumed future workplace discrimination based on offensive speech.
- French calls this a 'Department of Pre-crime' logic that wrongly infers misconduct from offense alone.
Don’t Escalate Cancellations
- Avoid 'turnabout is fair play' escalation; retaliatory cancellations only increase polarization.
- French warns escalation doesn't solve the problem and simply deepens cultural division.