The Jimmy Kimmel canceling is a tipping point for democracy

Sep 19, 2025

Dr. Vince Greenwood, a scholar and clinician specializing in psychopathy, joins John Gartner and Harry Segal to unpack Trump's troubling behavior. They diagnose a mix of malignant narcissism and sociopathy, warning of its implications for democracy. The trio explores how Trump exploits tragedies, like Charlie Kirk’s murder, to suppress dissent and stoke division. Greenwood sheds light on how psychopathic traits enable manipulation and authoritarianism, leaving audiences pondering the dangerous combination of charisma and remorselessness in leadership.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Malignant Personality Driving Authoritarian Risk

John Gartner and Harry Segal argue Trump's behavior shows malignant narcissism combined with sociopathic traits that threaten democracy.
They link compulsive lying, criminality, and institutional attacks to a deeper pathology driving authoritarianism.

INSIGHT

Tragedy Weaponized To Suppress Dissent

The hosts say the Kirk assassination is being politicized as a tool to demonize the left and suppress dissent.
They describe grief being hijacked to justify repression and erode free speech and pluralism.

INSIGHT

Presidential Rhetoric Reframes Crime As Political Threat

Trump's Oval Office remarks framed the murder as caused by 'radical left' demonization and promised to hunt funders and organizations.
Hosts warn that framing creates a false narrative used to criminalize critics and expand state power.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

Your favorite psychologists, John Gartner and Harry Segal, review the insidious way the Trump administration is using the Kirk assassination to end freedom of speech. They are joined again by Dr. Vince Greenwood, an expert on psychopathy, who shines a spotlight on Trump’s criminal behavior.

Be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts:

Our site

Subscribe on iTunes

Subscribe on Spotify

Subscribe on Amazon Music

Subscribe on iHeartRadio

The episode opens with a stark diagnosis: Trump’s behavior reflects a dangerous blend of malignant narcissism and sociopathy. Gartner and Segal argue that his compulsive lying, criminality, and relentless attacks on institutions aren’t just political tactics—they’re symptoms of a deeper pathology. These traits, they warn, fuel a pattern of authoritarian maneuvering that threatens the very fabric of democratic society.

One of the most chilling segments centers on the political exploitation of tragedy. In the wake of Charlie Kirk’s murder, Trump and his allies swiftly weaponized the event to stoke anti-left sentiment and suppress dissent. Gartner and Segal dissect this response as a textbook example of fear-based control, where grief is hijacked to justify repression. They argue that this tactic not only deepens national division but also corrodes core democratic principles like free speech and pluralism.

The conversation then turns to media complicity. The psychologists critique how certain outlets, under financial or ideological pressure, have surrendered their independence and become echo chambers for Trump’s narrative. This media capture, they contend, is not incidental—it’s strategic. By dominating the information ecosystem, Trump consolidates power and silences opposition, turning journalism into a tool of authoritarian control.

Joining the discussion is Dr. Vince Greenwood, who offers a clinical assessment of Trump as a psychopath. Drawing on established diagnostic criteria, Greenwood highlights traits like impulsivity, lack of remorse, and a compulsive need to dominate. While these traits have helped Trump rise, Greenwood warns they may also be his undoing. The very pathology that fuels his power could expose vulnerabilities—cracks in the armor of authoritarianism.

The episode closes with a call to action. Gartner and Segal urge listeners to stay vigilant, resist normalization, and confront the psychological tactics that enable authoritarian rule. Understanding the cognitive and behavioral patterns of leaders, they argue, isn’t just academic—it’s essential to defending democracy.

Tune in next week for another gripping, clinically grounded exploration of power, pathology, and the urgent need to protect democratic values from psychological manipulation.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices