Episode 206: The Thundering Herd, The Vanishing American
Aug 17, 2023
auto_awesome
Exploring the mysterious origins of bison on Catalina Island, the decline of the American buffalo population, preservation efforts by the American Bison Society, the connection between saving bison and Nazi ideology, and the purpose and population of herds on Catalina Island.
The American Bison Society, while aiming to preserve the buffalo species, had troubling undertones of racism and eugenics through its founder Madison Grant and his book that influenced Nazi ideology.
Buffalo herds serve two primary purposes today: conservation herds help restore western ecosystems, while the majority are raised as livestock for meat consumption.
Deep dives
Origins of Catalina Island's Bison Herd
Catalina Island's famous bison herd has a mysterious origin. While popular theories attribute their presence to movies like 'The Vanishing American' and 'The Thundering Heard,' both theories have been debunked. The truth likely involves an unknown movie or an endeavor by the island's owners, the Riggly chewing gum family. In the early 19th century, the American buffalo population faced rapid decline due to hunting, railroad expansion, and industrial exploitation. By 1884, there were only 300 to 500 buffalo left alive. The American Bison Society, co-founded by Madison Grant, aimed to preserve the species but was motivated by concerns over 'interbreeding' with cattle rather than conservation. Grant, a racist and eugenicist, penned a book that influenced Nazi ideology and the Holocaust. Through efforts like moving 15 buffalo to Oklahoma in 1907, the American Bison Society made strides in saving the buffalo, eventually resulting in the current population of approximately 450,000 buffalo today.
Buffalo Conservation and Livestock
Today, there are two primary purposes for buffalo herds: conservation and livestock. An estimated 20,000 buffalo live in conservation herds, helping restore balance to western ecosystems and rectify past damage. The remaining 430,000 buffalo are raised as livestock, mainly for meat consumption. The significance of buffalo preservation is highlighted by the 150-strong herd on Catalina Island, safeguarded by the Catalina Island Conservancy. These buffalo are free from predators, surrounded by the island's natural beauty, and coexist with the island's human activities, such as bachelorette parties and wine festivals.
Memory Palace Achievements and Controversies
The Memory Palace podcast delves into the history of the American buffalo and its conservation efforts. While the American Bison Society can be commended for raising awareness and lobbying Congress, its founder, Madison Grant, was also a racist and eugenicist. Grant's ideas about preserving the 'Nordic' race aligned with Nazi ideology and his book was praised by Adolf Hitler. Despite the achievements of the American Bison Society, caution is needed when viewing early environmental movements, as they often had troubling undertones of racism and pseudo-science to advance their causes.
The Memory Palace is a proud member of Radiotopia from PRX.
Music
Halcyon and Photosynteses and Embryo by H. Takehashi
Intro by Library Tapes
The Florist Wears Knee Breeches by M. Sage
Notes
I found Andrew Isenberg's book, The Destruction of the Bison, An Environmental History, completely fascinating.
If you want to do a deep dive on Madison Grant, I'd recommend Defending the Master Race: Conservation, Eugenics, and the Legacy of Madison Grant by John Peter Spiro.
If you want to do a deep dive on the Catalina Buffalo, this site is a fun place to start.