#STRask Would the Disciples Die for a Lie If They Believed It Was for the Greater Good?
Jan 13, 2025
The discussion explores whether the disciples would die for a lie, weighing fear and confusion against the premise of altruism. It also addresses how to thoughtfully engage with a Hindu Uber customer, advocating for curiosity and open dialogue. In addition, the podcast examines differing perceptions of God's existence, empowering listeners to tackle skepticism with respect and philosophical reasoning. The insights shared encourage deeper reflection on faith and truth.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Disciples' Motivation for Martyrdom
- Richard Carrier suggests the disciples might have died for a lie they believed promoted a greater good.
- This is implausible given their fear and lack of foresight after Jesus' crucifixion.
Jewish Perspective on Moral Reformation
- The disciples, as Jews, already had the law for moral reformation.
- Promoting a false god wouldn't align with their beliefs, making Carrier's theory unlikely.
Conversation Starter for Hinduism
- Start a conversation with someone going to a Hindu temple by simply asking "Why?".
- Follow up with questions about their motivations and understanding of truth.