The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Massive Mailbag, Lane Kiffin fallout, Do the Brown have a good roster
Dec 3, 2025
This episode dives into the Lane Kiffin saga and the turbulent situation at Ole Miss. There's an intriguing discussion on the Browns' roster talent despite their struggles. John also evaluates quarterbacks' reclamation projects. He argues that the NFL won't adopt a mercy rule due to business incentives. The show wraps with insights on coaching longevity, Kevin O'Connell’s future in Minnesota, and the dynamics of player success versus team achievements. It's a lively mix of team analysis and expert commentary in the world of football.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Quarterback And Coaching Drive Sustained Success
- Sustained team success hinges on elite quarterback play and consistent coaching continuity.
- John Middlecoff cites the Chiefs and 49ers as examples where core players plus steady coaching drive long-term success.
Use Medical Reports To Make Educated Bets
- Trust team doctors' evaluations during drafts but recognize medical opinions are probabilistic.
- Use medical reports to make educated bets, not absolute guarantees about a player's durability.
College Coach Poaching Creates Gray Areas
- Coaching offers and midseason poaching create gray areas because college programs operate without strict hiring rules.
- Ole Miss faced desperation balancing playoff chances with losing coaches to LSU, illustrating that turmoil changes incentives.