The Athletic Hockey Show Is Nathan MacKinnon better than Connor McDavid?
Dec 3, 2025
Frankie Corrado, a former NHL defenseman and insightful contributor, dives into the heated debate of whether Nathan MacKinnon is currently outshining Connor McDavid. The discussion highlights Colorado's explosive start and McKinnon's impressive goal-scoring and intensity. They also touch on the struggling Winnipeg Jets, impacted by the loss of star goalie Connor Hellebuyck. Plus, the emergence of rookie Jesper Wallstedt revitalizes the Minnesota Wild, sparking comparisons for the Calder Trophy. A thrilling blend of stats, anecdotes, and hockey insights!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
McKinnon Is The Top Player Right Now
- Nathan McKinnon is playing at a level that makes him the best player in the NHL right now according to the hosts.
- Sean McIndoe and Sean Gentille argue McKinnon's November scoring surge and team impact justify that temporary leap over Connor McDavid.
Net Impact Beats Name Recognition
- McKinnon's on-ice goal differential and scoring aggressiveness underpin his argument for being the league's top player.
- Gentille highlights the Avs outscoring opponents 37-9 when McKinnon is on the ice and his willingness to shoot from dangerous areas.
Context Explains McDavid's Dip
- McIndoe and Gentille note context matters: McDavid's heavy playoff mileage and team reliance may explain his dip.
- They argue McKinnon's current goal-scoring ferocity makes him a more potent shooter than McDavid this season.
