Jess documents Judy's life struggles in exchange for help, causing complications in their relationships. The focus shifts to handling chaos, facing eviction, and navigating personal boundaries. Michael shares his post-prison challenges of isolation and trust. The series delves into personal transformation, blurred relationships, and finalizing the narrative with feedback.
The challenges of maintaining professional boundaries while documenting the lives of vulnerable subjects.
The importance of ethical storytelling practices and considering the potential impact on the individuals being portrayed.
Deep dives
Judy's Housing Struggle and Legal Emergency
Judy, a shelter resident, faces a critical legal emergency amidst her housing instability. Struggling to coordinate schedules, Judy's intent becomes unclear. Jess reacts with empathy and tries to connect her with legal aid.
Michael's Complicated Past and Housing Turmoil
Michael, a writer and former inmate, shares his journey post-prison. Juggling low-paying jobs and housing insecurity, Jess wrestles with capturing Michael's story authentically. Challenges arise as Michael's narrative veers into cliches and lacks specificity.
Jess's Discomfort with Boundaries and Shift in Dynamics
Jess navigates blurred boundaries with Michael, leading to discomfort and professional clarification. Recognizing their differing priorities and the need for a clear distinction, a balance between collaboration and a professional relationship is sought.
Documentary's Impact on Subjects and Ethical Dilemma
As the series nears completion, Jess grapples with the unintended impacts on her subjects. The documentary's original intent faces scrutiny, with concerns on potentially harmful consequences for Judy and Michael. Uncertainty lingers as a reflection on storytelling ethics and relationships emerges.
Jess makes a deal with Judy, an unhoused senior. Judy will let Jess document her, and Jess will help Judy resolve some of her ongoing life problems. As Jess gets sucked into Judy's crises, the rest of the series starts to slip and Jess’ relationships with her other subjects get messy. Jess starts to doubt the premise of this entire undertaking.
Shocking, Heartbreaking, Transformative is written, hosted and produced by Jess Shane. Sara Nics is the story editor. Sound design, mix/mastering by Michelle Macklem. Production support from Mona Hassan. Cover art is by Justin Broadbent. Jess’s bibliography is available here.
This reporting was supported in part by the International Women’s Media Foundation’s Howard G.Buffett Fund for Women Journalists.
Special thanks to Eleanor McDowall and Chioke I’Anson.
For Radiotopia Presents, Yooree Losordo is the managing producer. Audrey Mardavich is the Executive Producer. It’s a production of PRX’s Radiotopia and part of Radiotopia Presents, a podcast feed that debuts limited-run, artist-owned series from new and original voices.
Learn more about Shocking, Heartbreaking, Transformative at radiotopiapresents.fm and discover more shows from across the Radiotopia network at radiotopia.fm.