Tim Spiers, a football writer for The Athletic, and Mark Critchley, a Manchester United expert, dive into the relevance of the FA Cup this season. They analyze which Premier League teams, like Tottenham and Newcastle, most need this tournament to regain momentum. The duo discusses Arsenal's quest for silverware under Mikel Arteta and Manchester United's struggles as holders. They also debate whether the FA Cup has lost its allure and reflect on nostalgic moments from past runs, highlighting the emotional connection it fosters among fans.
Tottenham Hotspur views the FA Cup as essential for rebuilding fan trust and restoring the club's historical legacy after recent struggles.
Newcastle United's pursuit of a domestic trophy this season reflects their ambition and the renewed hope from the recent ownership changes.
Deep dives
Everton's Managerial Shake-Up
Sean Dyche was relieved of his duties as Everton's manager following a poor performance against Bournemouth, which led to discussions of a managerial change. This decision came just hours before a crucial FA Cup match, raising questions about the timing and rationale behind it. The Friedkin group, new owners of Everton, reportedly favored David Moyes as a replacement, hoping to stabilize the club and avoid relegation. The context of managerial turnover and the club's ongoing financial issues underline the challenges Everton faces as they navigate their future.
The Significance of the FA Cup for Tottenham
Tottenham Hotspur fans ranked the FA Cup as crucial for the club this season, driven by a need for success after years of underperformance in the competition. Coach Ange Postacoglu emphasized a historical gap since Spurs last secured the FA Cup, citing their struggles and pushing for a strong cup run this year. The squad's recent performance, including impressive victories over top-tier teams, reflects their potential to contend. For Spurs, reclaiming glory in the FA Cup is seen as vital for restoring the fanbase's faith and the club's legacy.
Newcastle’s Trophies Drought and Expectations
Newcastle United's supporters expressed a strong desire for a trophy, acknowledging that the club has not claimed a domestic title in over 70 years. With a current pathway in both the FA Cup and League Cup, fans are hopeful for a successful run that would highlight the team's progress since the recent takeover. The club's resurgence has seen them rise in the league standings, and they are positioned to challenge for silverware. A trophy this season would not only fulfill fan expectations but also validate the investment and efforts of the new ownership.
Arsenal's Quest for Silverware
Mikel Arteta's Arsenal finds itself in a critical position, with increasing fan frustration over their lack of trophies in recent seasons. The FA Cup holds significance as they aim to demonstrate the progress made under his management after falling short in league competitiveness. With recent injuries affecting their performance and questions about squad depth emerging, this cup represents a chance for redemption. Winning the FA Cup would not only alleviate pressure but also assure supporters of a trajectory towards major honors.
With the FA Cup is upon us again, we're asking which Premier League side needs the competition most this season?
Tottenham and Newcastle lead the way on the The Athletic's Import-o-meter, with both sides currently on course to meet in the Carabao Cup final.
FA Cup holders Manchester United head to the Emirates to face record 14-time winners Arsenal, who since winning the competition in 2020 have not progressed past the fourth round. Does Mikel Arteta need a trophy this season? And how will Ruben Amorim's progress be measured?
Plus - outside shouts for Bournemouth and Brentford, and has the FA Cup lost its magic?