George Eaton, Senior Editor at the New Statesman, and Rachel Cunliffe, Associate Political Editor, dive into the dynamics of Labour's recent growth speech. They discuss whether the party's efforts are genuine or merely a change in rhetoric. The duo also tackles the charisma gap surrounding leaders Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves, revealing how this impacts voter connection. Additionally, they explore the media’s treatment of the Liberal Democrats, highlighting the challenges of gaining coverage in a tense political atmosphere.
Labour's recent growth shift aims to improve living standards through higher productivity, yet critics question the effectiveness of their strategies.
The tension between promoting economic growth and adhering to necessary regulations highlights the need for balanced and innovative policy approaches.
Deep dives
Government's Approach to Economic Growth
The government is aiming for economic growth despite concerns that their methods may be misguided. This shift from previous gloomy rhetoric to a focus on growth indicates a response to the dire economic situation, with the Chancellor's recent speech described as an attempt at revitalizing the economy. The government's focus on economic growth is tied to improving living standards and public services, as higher productivity is deemed necessary to support these areas in the long run. Critics, however, question whether the strategy will be effective, pointing to potential challenges and historical parallels with previous government shifts that failed to deliver results.
Reviving Old Ideas for Growth
The government’s plans to invest in the Oxford-Cambridge corridor, a long-discussed initiative, has raised concerns about the reliance on outdated strategies rather than innovative solutions. While proponents argue that these long-standing ideas could be immediately implemented to address current needs, critics see this as merely recycling old concepts without truly addressing regional disparities in growth. The need for a balanced approach that fosters growth across various UK regions, rather than just the South East, remains a pressing issue. Critics also emphasize the importance of formulating new ideas tailored to the pressing economic climate, rather than rehashing those from previous administrations.
Tensions in Policy and Regulation
There is an ongoing tension between the desire for economic growth and the need for adequate regulation, highlighted by conflicting policy announcements. For instance, the government's commitment to expand Heathrow Airport contradicts their net-zero targets, which has led to accusations of panic-driven decision-making. Additionally, the debate surrounding the balance of regulation reflects broader concerns about how cutting red tape can lead to safety oversights, particularly in light of past tragedies like Grenfell. The push for 'good growth' emphasizes sustainability and regional balance, challenging the government to ensure that its growth strategies do not come at the cost of essential regulations that protect public welfare.
Rachel Reeves' latest growth speech has failed to convince one curious listener.
George Eaton and Rachel Cunliffe join Hannah Barnes for a special listener questions episode. They tackle your questions on Labour's latest intervention on growth, which George describes as an "attempt" at a vibe shift.
They also discuss whether Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves have a charisma problem, as well as one listener who asks if the media should be giving the Liberal Democrats more attention.
Ask a question for us to answer in a future episode: www.newstatesman.com/youaskus
Get more politics coverage every day direct to your email inbox by signing up for our daily politics newsletter: morningcall.substack.com
Save money on a New Statesman subscription to get full access to all our reporting and analysis from just £5 for your first 5 weeks: www.newstatesman.com/jan25