Minds Almost Meeting Perfection vs. greatness (Robin Hanson & Agnes Callard)
34 snips
Jan 23, 2025 Two intellects collide as they grapple with the tension between perfectionism and greatness. The discussion dives into how educational norms may stifle creativity and the effects of conformity in various fields. They explore whether strict procedures enhance or hinder success, using reality TV as a vivid example. A critical look at the burden of perfection reveals its impact on innovation and true achievement. Ultimately, they question how cultural uniformity can both aid communication and suppress creative thought.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Shifting Disciplinary Regimes
- Agnes Callard discusses Foucault's concept of shifting disciplinary regimes.
- She contrasts an exclusionary regime of greatness with a conformist regime of normalization.
Liability vs. Regulation
- Robin Hanson draws parallels between liability/regulation and outcome/procedure-based regimes.
- He discusses how these regimes apply to various fields like art, law, and education.
Reality TV and Outcome Orientation
- Robin Hanson observes that reality TV shows like cooking or fashion design competitions often emphasize outcome orientation.
- These shows focus on greatness and not strictly following procedures.