739: John Brooke, part 1: Deep history and how our culture formed
Dec 24, 2023
auto_awesome
Exploring deep history and how our culture formed, the podcast discusses the impact of agriculture, the formation of dominance hierarchies, and the role of bronze metallurgy. It also delves into the Enlightenment, slavery, abolitionism, and the importance of creating a culture of joy and connection around environmental values.
The transition from the Pleistocene to the Holocene influenced the emergence of agriculture and the formation of dominance hierarchies in human societies.
Technological advancements, such as the discovery of bronze and the development of agriculture, played a significant role in shaping human history and the expansion of dominance hierarchies.
The shift from hunter-gatherer societies to settled agriculture led to increased sickness among populations, eventually forcing the adoption of agriculture and changing cleanliness and public health practices.
Deep dives
Transition from Pleistocene to Holocene
The transition from the Pleistocene to the Holocene marked a significant shift in human history. The Pleistocene was a period of extreme climate fluctuations and ice ages, while the Holocene was an interglacial period. The transition from the Pleistocene to the Holocene was influenced by factors such as changing Earth systems and human population dynamics. Agriculture emerged during this period, driven by the need for increased food production and survival in a changing environment. Populations grew, technologies advanced, and societies became more hierarchical as surplus resources led to competition and the formation of dominance hierarchies.
The Role of Technology and Environmental Context
Technological advancements, such as the discovery of bronze and the development of agriculture, played a significant role in shaping human history. Bronze metallurgy led to the rise of dominance hierarchies, as access to bronze weapons provided power and dominance over others. Similarly, the gradual emergence of agriculture was influenced by factors such as population density, environmental changes, and the development of specialized tools. The availability of surplus resources and the need to protect them also contributed to the expansion of dominance hierarchies. Additionally, the environmental context, including climate shifts and access to valuable resources, like metals and textiles, influenced human societal and technological development.
Inevitability and Competition
The development of human societies and the expansion of dominance hierarchies can be viewed as partly inevitable due to the human capacity for ingenuity and problem-solving. Once surpluses of resources, such as food and materials, were available, competition for these resources drove the formation and expansion of dominance hierarchies. These hierarchies sought to protect their resources and expand their influence, leading to imperialism and the acquisition of valuable commodities. Environmental context, technological advancements, and human behavior all interacted to shape the trajectory of human history, emphasizing the complex interplay between human agency and the surrounding environment.
Transition from hunter-gatherer to settled societies
The podcast discusses the transition from hunter-gatherer societies to settled agricultural societies, highlighting the impact this shift had on cleanliness and public health. It suggests that as humans settled into one place, trash and germs accumulated, leading to increased sickness among the population. The earliest settled societies, such as the Tepe and Çatalhöyük, were found to have messy living conditions. The podcast proposes that the earlier populations may have become sicker and lost their skills for movement, which eventually resulted in the forced adoption of agriculture.
The role of climate change in the emergence of agriculture
The podcast explores the connection between climate change and the emergence of agriculture. It emphasizes the importance of productive and predictable plant growth for communities to make the transition to settled agriculture. The availability of CO2 in the atmosphere was considered a crucial factor in this process. The ability to store biomass through time was essential for survival during periods of climate variability. The podcast also touches on the unintended consequences of agriculture, such as the development of dominance hierarchies and the need to protect and control resources.
Greenhouse gas and ocean plastic levels don't rise on their own. The cause of our environmental problems is our behavior, which results from our culture. The world's dominant culture pollutes, depletes, addicts, and imperially takes over other cultures. Yet each person wants clean air, land, water, and food.
How did humans create a culture that manifests the opposite of many of their values? Why do most people defend that culture, resist changing it, and promote it, even when faced with evidence that it's sickening them, isolating them, killing them, and risking killing billions more within our lifetimes? If we can't answer these questions, we'll have a hard time changing our culture and therefore the disasters we're sleepwalking into.
I've been trying to answer them. Learning about our ancestral past for 250,000 years before agriculture, why and how agriculture started, and what changes agriculture prompted tells us. John Brooke's book, Climate Change and the Course of Global History: A Rough Journey, starts to answer these questions. It's a book of deep history and environmental history---that is, going back hundreds of thousands and even millions of years, treating how environmental changes influenced human behavior.
John and I talk about the field of deep history, how we learn the incredible detailed and fascinating histories of how environments changed and people reacted over many time scales. I would find the scholarship fascinating on its own, and all the more because it's relevant to our environmental situation today. Changes that started twelve thousand years ago started patterns that persist today. In fact, some of them are the dominant factors in how we interact with the environment, in particular how dominance hierarchies formed, what patterns they set into our culture, and how they persist.
I hadn't heard of this field before his book. If you hadn't either, you'll love it.
(He also studies American history including slavery and abolitionism, another relevant part of history. We'll cover them in our next conversation.)