
Whiskey Ginger with Andrew Santino Caitlin Peluffo loves a short king 👑| Whiskey Ginger
Oct 2, 2026
Caitlin Peluffo, an energetic stand-up comedian seen on The Tonight Show and Comedy Central, brings her lovable chaos to a candid conversation about college soccer, drinking, breakups, dating apps, and disastrous travel. They debate New York versus California, comedy competitions, bombing onstage, family at dirty shows, and the elusive search for a funny short king.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
How Partying Ended Caitlin’s Soccer Career
- Caitlin Peluffo lost her college soccer spot after spending the summer partying and abandoning her fitness routine.
- She refused a redshirt comeback because it would have stretched college to six years, choosing embarrassment over prolonging the setback.
Caitlin’s Wild Soccer Team Initiation
- Caitlin Peluffo’s soccer initiation involved Malibu rum, push-ups, a cavewoman costume, fake breasts, handcuffs, and humiliating challenges.
- The experience became an early example of her willingness to embrace embarrassment rather than resist it.
Why Caitlin Falls For Broken People
- Caitlin Peluffo says casual dating is difficult because she quickly shifts from wanting sex to wanting emotional connection.
- Her pattern is less instant infatuation than an urge to rescue or improve someone she sees as broken.



