The Fallacy of Theological Fatalism

Theological fatalism, as discussed in the podcast, presents a problematic framework for understanding the relationship between divine prophecy and human freedom. Critics claim that if Jesus prophesied Judas's betrayal, then it inevitably must occur, leading to the conclusion that Judas's choices are irrelevant. This reasoning misinterprets the nature of prophetic knowledge, failing to recognize that the fulfillment of prophecy does not eliminate the possibility of alternate choices. Moreover, the distinction between necessity in the composite and divided sense illustrates that while Judas's betrayal was prophesied, he maintained the freedom to act differently, thus countering the fatalistic position.