Episode 268: “Best of” Series: An Experiment in Criticism, Ch. 10-Epilogue
Mar 18, 2025
auto_awesome
The discussion kicks off with insights on poetry, emphasizing the sound and experience of the written word. Angelina and Thomas share their favorite literary resources, underlining the importance of staying true to the text. They explore the nuances of marginalia and its impact on reading. The conversation delves into the purpose of literature: to enrich our souls and broaden our perspectives. A thought-provoking question emerges: will we approach reading with hubris or humility? This exploration of literary criticism invites listeners to deepen their understanding of texts.
Engaging with literature requires understanding its nuances and cultural context, leading to a richer personal experience and broader perspective.
The podcast critiques elitism in literary criticism, advocating for an inclusive approach that values diverse genres and readers' experiences.
Literature serves as both a mirror reflecting personal experiences and a window offering insights into different lives, promoting empathy and growth.
Deep dives
The Importance of Reading Well
Reading well is not solely about the act itself but also about engaging deeply with the material. The podcast highlights that truly appreciating literature involves understanding its nuances, themes, and the cultural context in which it was produced. This means that readers need to be open to the tradition and intellectual lineage behind classic works, rather than approaching them with a superficial desire for entertainment. The hosts emphasize that good literature serves as a means of enriching one's personal experience by allowing readers to transcend their individual limits and engage with the collective wisdom contained within great texts.
Rediscovering Literary Traditions
The discussion underscores the need to reconnect with lost literary traditions that have shaped our understanding of stories and imagination. The speakers assert that much of contemporary reading culture has strayed from traditional narratives, leading to a more diminished appreciation for profound storytelling. They make a compelling case for exploring and reviving historical literary practices as a way to enrich modern reading experiences. By engaging with classic texts and the mythological roots they are based upon, readers can cultivate a richer, more informed literary life.
Critique of Snobbery in Literature
In a critique of elitism within literary criticism, the speakers discuss the dangers of self-proclaimed experts who dismiss entire genres or authors based on narrow criteria. This snobbery not only limits the scope of literature but also discourages new and diverse readers from exploring various types of writing. They emphasize that good literature can appear in many forms, and the true value of a book is not solely judged by its standing in academic circles. The hosts encourage readers to embrace literature from all backgrounds, asserting that a genuine literary experience transcends conventional definitions of 'good' or 'bad.'
The Role of Critics and Scholars
The podcast elaborates on the valuable role of literary critics and scholars in enhancing the reading experience without overshadowing the text itself. Critics should function as guides who illuminate key aspects of a work, helping readers understand its context, language, and themes. The discussion contrasts this approach with evaluative criticism, which seeks to judge and rate literature, often alienating readers. By focusing on enabling meaningful engagement with texts, critics can foster a more enriching dialogue between literature and its readers.
Literature as a Mirror and Window
A central theme in the podcast is the dual nature of literature as both a mirror and a window. Literature serves as a mirror, reflecting personal experiences and emotions, while also acting as a window, offering insights into lives and perspectives vastly different from one's own. The speakers argue that this duality is crucial for personal growth and understanding, as engaging with diverse narratives can foster empathy and broaden one's worldview. By embracing both aspects, readers can benefit from literature as a tool for transformative experiences.
Embracing Literary Humility
The speakers stress the necessity of humility in literary engagement, encouraging readers to approach texts with an open mind rather than preconceived notions. This attitude allows readers to fully immerse themselves in the material, fostering a richer understanding of the narrative and its significance. By letting go of the desire to judge or critique too quickly, readers can appreciate the layers and meanings within a work. The podcast conveys the idea that literary journeys are best navigated through a blend of humility and curiosity, enabling a deeper connection with the literature.
On today’s “Best of” episode of The Literary Life, Angelina and Cindy are once again joined by Thomas Banks. They discuss the last two chapters and the epilogue of An Experiment in Criticism. The first topic of conversation is Lewis’ comments on poetry, including the un-literary reading of poetry and the importance of the sound of poetry. Angelina highlights Lewis’ take on reading “bad books,” and Cindy points out his warning against de-bunking. Thomas gives us some history on the reference to F. R. Leavis and his literary criticism.
Angelina dives into her favorite part of this section, all about what makes good literary criticism. She recaps Lewis’ own list of the types of literary commentators and historians who have helped him in his own reading. Angelina and Thomas both mention some of their favorite resources, including George Lyman Kittredge, Northrup Frye, J. W. MacKail and Dorothy Sayers. Another important point is to look for resources that point back to the text, not outside of the text.
Cindy and Angelina clear up some confusion about marginalia and what types of notes can help or hinder us in our reading. Finally, in discussing the epilogue, our hosts reiterate the purpose of reading as widening our souls and freeing ourselves to experience another person’s perspective. Cindy asks if we will read with hubris, or humility? That makes all the difference.
Join us right here again next week for a brand new episode on An Experiment in Criticism in which Angelina and Thomas will revisit the book and answer some listener questions from over the years!
The seventh annual Literary Life Online Conference is coming very soon! Please visit HouseofHumaneLetters.com to sign up for that as well as all the other upcoming webinars of 2025!
