Jennifer Doliak, an economist and criminal justice policy expert at Arnold Ventures, discusses the intricate relationship between policing and public safety. She delves into the effect of societal reforms on crime rate declines and the paradox of how protests for police accountability can lead to rising crime. Doliak highlights surprising links between air pollution and violent crime, as well as the need for better police training. Additionally, she emphasizes the importance of community engagement to address racial dynamics and promote long-term safety.
Racial healing is essential for fostering community connections and understanding the intricate histories that shape racial dynamics.
The preference for addressing social issues over reinforcing law enforcement suggests a belief in long-term social investment as crime reduction strategy.
A balanced approach combining effective policing with robust social investments is necessary for comprehensive community safety strategies.
Deep dives
The Importance of Racial Healing
Racial healing is emphasized as a universal need that transcends individual experiences, urging a deeper understanding of personal and communal histories. This initiative aims to foster connections and unveil the realities of racial dynamics within communities, promoting discussions that lead to collective visions for achieving racial equity. The National Day of Racial Healing, observed on January 21st, 2025, serves as a catalyst for initiating these crucial conversations. Engaging in these dialogues not only enhances awareness but also encourages communities to collaborate towards positive change.
Public Perception of Crime Reduction Strategies
A recent Gallup poll highlights a significant public inclination towards addressing social issues such as drug addiction and homelessness to tackle crime, rather than solely reinforcing law enforcement. This puzzling preference suggests a prevailing belief that social investment is perceived as a more effective long-term solution to crime reduction. However, this binary choice does not fully acknowledge the potential for a multi-faceted approach that includes both social programs and policing. The monetary constraints faced by local governments in managing these priorities complicate the public discourse around optimal crime-fighting strategies.
The Long-Term Decline in Crime Rates
Pre-pandemic, crime rates across the United States saw a significant long-term decline, particularly in violent crime. Various theories have emerged to explain this trend, including increased policing and socio-economic factors stemming from earlier anti-poverty efforts. These changes, combined with environmental factors like reduced lead exposure, have contributed to this decrease, albeit with uncertainty around exact causative links. The complexities of these trends underline the need for nuanced analysis rather than attributing declines solely to any one intervention.
Investing in Policing vs. Social Programs
Research indicates that hiring more police officers tends to correlate with a reduction in crime rates, particularly for violent offenses. Nevertheless, the idea that increased funding for social welfare programs could render police obsolete is a contentious one, as the immediate efficacy of police presence often outweighs long-term interventions. While investing in social programs, such as summer jobs for youth or education, presents significant potential for crime prevention, their benefits may take years to materialize. Therefore, a balanced approach that includes both effective policing and robust social investments is essential for comprehensive community safety strategies.
Evaluating the Costs of Policing
The conversation around the impacts of policing includes concern for negative externalities, especially regarding harassment and brutality within communities. Research is ongoing to understand the balance between the benefits of policing and the potential for harm due to excessive or misguided tactics. Recent studies suggest that procedural justice training could mitigate some negative outcomes by fostering better interactions between police and communities. Ultimately, finding effective policing strategies that minimize harm while maintaining public safety is a crucial goal for law enforcement reform.
Four years ago, the murder of George Floyd—and the international protests that followed—amplified calls to defund or abolish the police. But what do we actually know about the relationship between policing and public safety?
Share understanding this holiday season. For less than $2 a week, give a yearlong Atlantic subscription to someone special. They’ll get unlimited access to Atlantic journalism, including magazine issues, narrated articles, puzzles, and more. Give today at TheAtlantic.com/podgift.
