When a Few Financial Institutions Control Everything, with John Coates
Feb 29, 2024
auto_awesome
The podcast delves into the dangers of financial consolidation, focusing on the power of the 'Big Four' index funds and private equity firms. They discuss the lack of transparency, challenges of concentrated financial power, and potential solutions for a more equitable economic system.
Financial consolidation by a few institutions threatens democracy and public interest in the economy.
Private equity involvement increases bankruptcy risk for acquired companies, raising concerns about its impact on businesses.
Deep dives
The Democratic Deficit in Capitalism
A key point discussed is the risk posed by a small group controlling a significant portion of the economy. This poses a challenge to the public interest and highlights a democratic deficit within capitalism, where actions may prioritize personal gains over societal benefit.
Impact of Private Equity on Bankruptcy Rates
The podcast touches on a study showing that companies acquired by private equity firms face a higher likelihood of bankruptcy compared to those without such acquisitions. This insight provokes a discussion on the consequences of private equity involvement in businesses.
Transparency in Private Equity and Index Funds
The conversation delves into the secrecy and lack of transparency within private equity and index funds. Issues related to lobbying, lack of disclosure, and the influence of these entities on market dynamics and governance structures are explored.
Proposals for Addressing Market Power and Transparency
Several proposals are raised to address the growing market power of private equity and the need for transparency in financial markets. Suggestions include increasing regulations in private markets, enhancing disclosure requirements, and exploring solutions like pass-through voting and investor assemblies. The potential challenges and political implications of implementing these measures are also considered.
In his recent book, "The Problem of Twelve: When a Few Financial Institutions Control Everything," Harvard law professor John Coates sheds light on the secrecy, lack of public accountability, concentrated power, and the disproportionate influence of a select few institutions in our financial system.
Coates joins Bethany and Luigi to dissect the potential dangers of this era of financial consolidation and explore possible solutions, including accountability and transparency, to ensure a more equitable economic system. Specifically examining the "Big Four" index funds (Vanguard, State Street, Fidelity, and BlackRock) — that collectively hold more than twenty percent of the votes in S&P 500 companies — and the transformative rise of private equity funds, they discuss the challenges posed by concentrated financial power and its impact on markets, economies, and society at large.
Show Notes:
Read an excerpt of Coates' book (Columbia Global Reports) on ProMarket
Revisitour earlier conversation with Hélène Landemore, referenced by Luigi in this episode