Lore Legends 62: The Little Things
Sep 15, 2025
Discover the beauty in the simple moments of life, as the journey takes a spooky turn to the haunted legacies of the Phelps family in Palmyra, New York. Delight in the playful ghost Sybil, who lingers in a museum, while local legends like the notorious Angola Pigman reveal how folklore shapes community identity. Uncover bizarre tales, including a ghost with four legs, and explore the chilling folklore of black dogs, deeply entwined with themes of death and loyalty. History meets the supernatural in this captivating narrative.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Phelps General Store Frozen In Time
- William Phelps converted a 1826 federal-style building into a family-run general store at 140 Market Street in Palmyra.
- The store closed suddenly in 1940 and stayed frozen in time while the family lived upstairs for decades.
Sybil, The Spiritualist Who Stayed
- Sybil Phelps lived upstairs until 1976 and practiced spiritualism with a crystal ball and mirrors.
- Museum staff report hearing her voice on EVPs and seeing her appear, telling a worker "don't touch my stuff."
A Ghostly Family Reunion
- The Phelps building's hauntings form a multi-generational "ghost family reunion" with distinct voices and child apparitions.
- Visitors report children like Holly grabbing hands and hiding under a table, blending playfulness with the uncanny.