Chris Hayes, MSNBC host and author of "The Siren's Call," dives into the complexities of the attention economy. He discusses how attention has evolved into a valuable commodity, highlighting its implications for society. Hayes explores the internal struggles of self-control in the digital age and the emotional toll of seeking validation online. He warns of potential dystopian outcomes from commodifying attention and emphasizes the need for collective action against misinformation and superficial engagement. The conversation touches on reclaiming the open internet for meaningful connections.
Attention is categorized into voluntary, involuntary, and social types, each reflecting different ways we engage with the world.
The attention economy prioritizes capturing fleeting attention over maintaining engagement, leading content creators to emphasize sensationalism over meaningfulness.
A decline in societal trust due to the attention economy fosters disengagement and impairs democratic discourse, necessitating counter-movements for restoration.
Deep dives
Understanding Attention: Types and Their Implications
Attention is categorized into three distinct types: voluntary, involuntary, and social attention. Voluntary attention involves the conscious focus of thought, where individuals intentionally direct their attention towards something, akin to a spotlight on a stage. In contrast, involuntary attention is compelled by external stimuli, like hearing a loud noise or a siren, directing focus without conscious effort. Social attention, a crucial third category, pertains to how we engage with others and how others engage with us, highlighting its deeper psychological implications as it reflects on our societal connections.
The Attention Economy's Competitive Landscape
In the attention economy, capturing attention is noticeably easier than maintaining it, creating a system where content creators and marketers constantly seek effective ways to gain fleeting spots of attention. This leads to a competitive race for grabbing involuntary attention, compelling creators to design increasingly sensational or shocking content to be noticed. The phenomenon emphasizes that while one can immediately shout to gain attention, sustaining that focus requires deeper engagement and thought, which is more difficult to accomplish. This competitive dynamic ultimately shifts towards creating content that merely entertains or provokes, rather than informs or sustains.
How Attention Functions as a Commodity
Attention has transitioned into the central commodity of the modern economy, overshadowing the importance of information itself due to its finite nature in contrast to the overwhelming availability of information. The commodification of attention leads to individuals becoming increasingly alienated from their own cognitive resources, much like workers in industrial settings faced alienation from their labor. With the relentless pull for users’ attention online, these individual experiences of attention are becoming standardized and quantified, creating a paradox where personal engagement is necessary for life yet systematically extracted as a market resource. This tension highlights the value of individual attention as an economic asset while simultaneously diminishing its intrinsic worth to each individual.
The Interplay of Trust and Attention in a Fragmented Society
A significant consequence of the attention economy is a decline in societal trust, leading to a disengaged citizenship that grapples with fragmented information sources. People increasingly mistrust traditional institutions, opting instead to rely on algorithms that, while providing information, often exacerbate the problem by failing to meet the deeper human need for shared recognition and connection. This loss of trust creates an environment where meaningful discourse and public engagement become nearly impossible, as attention is drawn frequently to sensationalism rather than constructive conversation. In this sense, the challenges presented by the attention economy reflect a broader crisis of trust that ultimately undermines democratic deliberation.
Looking Ahead: Rebuilding Attention and Trust
The future holds potential for redefining relationships with attention, as individuals begin to recognize the downsides of excessive engagement with attention-capturing media and start to seek out alternative experiences. Movements toward non-commercial and community-based spaces—akin to farmers' markets for attention—could provide a counterbalance to the overwhelming nature of the current digital landscape, allowing for more meaningful interchange and less distraction. Activism, reforms, and individual choices will be crucial in pushing back against the structures of attention capitalism that have come to dominate lives and society at large. Ultimately, the reclamation of attention must be tied to the restoration of trust, fostering environments where democratic institutions can thrive again.
Chris Hayes — author, MSNBC host, and previous guest on Volts — is just out with a new book, The Sirens Call, about the corrosive effects of the modern attention economy. In this episode, he and I dive deep into attention: what it is, when it became commodified, why it is so easy to steal, where industry is looking for new supplies, and how the harried and distracted can defend themselves from the onslaught.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.volts.wtf/subscribe
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
