Episode 410 Promo - Kamala vs. The Black Left (w/ Dr. Charisse Burden-Stelly)
Sep 30, 2024
auto_awesome
Dr. Charisse Burden-Stelly, a Wayne University scholar renowned for her political insights, shares her take on Kamala Harris's endorsements from the radical Black left. She discusses the implications of Jill Stein and Butch Ware's viral appearance on The Breakfast Club, along with Ta-Nehisi Coates’ anti-Zionist narrative in New York Magazine. In a lively debate, Dr. CBS and Brie tackle the left's strategy after the Squad's failing 'inside approach,' emphasizing the need for accountability in electoral politics and its role in fostering mass movements.
Dr. Charisse Burden-Stelly critiques electoral motivations within the Black left, emphasizing the need for a transformative grassroots approach beyond conventional voting strategies.
The discussion contrasts the impact of identity politics versus collective activism, suggesting that true social movements often arise from the efforts of marginalized groups rather than politicians.
Deep dives
Electoral Politics and Responsibility
Angela Davis discusses the complex relationship between electoral politics and the responsibility to vote within a specific political context. While she highlights that voting for candidates like Barack Obama and suggesting a ‘fascist adjacent’ option during critical elections may be a necessary strategy, she raises concerns about misleading narratives regarding candidates' potential benefits. This reflects a broader critique of liberal thought, exemplified by the sentiment that the left may find allies within the Democratic Party, which Davis contests by pointing out cases like Cori Bush and Rashida Tlaib who face isolation within Congress. Overall, she asserts that prioritizing electoral needs over urgent social justice issues, such as addressing genocide, can exacerbate existing problems and mislead constituents about the political reality.
The Importance of Organizing Beyond Elections
Davis emphasizes the necessity of organizing grassroots movements that extend beyond mere electoral success, indicating that victories should not be mistaken for true progress. She illustrates that the election of a black president was significant not because of his policies, but due to the mobilization efforts from young activists who defied the odds. Furthermore, she expresses skepticism about the notion that a politician’s identity alone will catalyze mass movements, citing a lack of evidence that Kamala Harris has inspired such activism. Instead, she highlights the historical context that shows real change often stems from collective action rather than the actions of those in power, regardless of their demographic characteristics.
1.
Reflections on Electoral Politics and Responsibility