Lieutenant Colonel Rory McGovern, an Associate Professor at West Point and co-author of a pivotal book on Black cadets, delves into the harrowing experiences of the first Black students at the U.S. Military Academy. He discusses the intense racism, hazing, and struggles for dignity faced by these trailblazers from 1870 to 1899. McGovern highlights James Webster Smith's journey as the first Black cadet and the historical significance of figures like Henry Ossian Flipper, shedding light on the ongoing fight for equality and representation in the military.
The early Black cadets at West Point faced systematic racism and harassment, highlighting the extensive challenges to their military aspirations.
Henry Ossian Flipper's graduation in 1877 marked a significant, yet complex milestone in integrating Black cadets into the U.S. Army's history.
Deep dives
The Experience of Early Black Cadets
In 1870, James Webster Smith and Michael Howard arrived at West Point with the aspiration of becoming the first Black cadets in its history. Their experience quickly turned troubling as they faced discrimination and harassment from fellow cadets, exemplified by an incident where a white candidate physically assaulted Howard for refusing to move out of the way. Despite reporting these attack, their claims were dismissed by West Point officials, who accused them of exaggerating to stir trouble. Ultimately, Howard left the academy, leaving Smith to navigate the challenges of being a Black cadet largely alone, which set the stage for the struggles that would follow.
Henry Ossian Flipper's Historic Graduation
On June 14, 1877, Henry Ossian Flipper became the first Black graduate of West Point, marking a significant milestone in its history. The graduation ceremony, attended by high-ranking military officials, featured unusual applause for Flipper, indicating a mixed reception given his experiences at the academy. His time at West Point was filled with hardship, including systemic racism and social isolation, yet his graduation symbolized the perseverance of Black cadets amid adversity. Flipper's achievement paved the way for future generations, despite the continued obstacles faced by others aiming for cadetship.
Challenges of Integration and Academic Rigorousness
The integration of Black cadets at West Point was fraught with difficulties, requiring them to endure an academically rigorous environment with an overwhelmingly hostile atmosphere. The entrance exams were incredibly challenging, with a lower admission rate for Black candidates like Smith, leading to extensive scrutiny of their performance. Throughout their time at the academy, Black cadets faced not only academic pressure but also active resistance, including harassment and physical assaults from white cadets, compounding their isolation as they navigated their studies. This systemic racism created barriers that made it extremely difficult for these pioneers to succeed.
Legacy and Evolution of Black Cadet Experiences
From Flipper in 1877 to Benjamin O. Davis Jr. in 1936, the journey for Black cadets at West Point changed slowly over time but was marked by continued challenges. While Flipper broke ground as the first graduate, the path forward included further instances of mistreatment and a significant gap before other Black graduates emerged, reflecting the racial dynamics of the era. The institution struggled to genuinely embrace integration, as evidenced by the ongoing social and academic hurdles that persisted throughout its history. Today, the legacies of these early Black cadets are recognized and celebrated, serving as testaments to their resilience and the gradual shift in the Army's approach to diversity and inclusion.
Between 1870 and 1899, only twelve Black cadets were admitted to the US military academy at West Point, and of those twelve, only three went on to graduate. Of the Black cadets who persevered, all faced relentless racial prejudice, hazing, ostracism, and silent treatment from their white peers. Today, Lindsay is joined by Lieutenant Colonel Rory McGovern to share stories of the early Black cadets who went through hell to try and obtain the prize of becoming an officer in the United States Army. Col. McGovern is the co-editor of Race, Politics, and Reconstruction: The First Black Cadets At Old West Point.
Be the first to know about Wondery’s newest podcasts, curated recommendations, and more! Sign up now at https://wondery.fm/wonderynewsletter
Listen to American History Tellers on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Experience all episodes ad-free and be the first to binge the newest season. Unlock exclusive early access by joining Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial today by visiting wondery.com/links/american-history-tellers/ now.